Black teenager plus two bikes plus recent thefts equals thief. She didn't consider any other explanation. She didn't think about the possibility that one of the bikes might be his and the other might belong to someone else for a legitimate reason. She didn't go outside to ask him what he was doing.
She just saw what she wanted to see, and what she saw confirmed her assumptions. She ended the call with her friend, pulled out her phone, and dialed 911. The dispatcher answered, "911, what's your emergency?" Melissa's voice came out urgent and breathless. "
There's a Black male, looks like a teenager, and he has two bikes. I think he's the one who's been stealing bikes in our neighborhood. You need to send someone right now before he gets away." The dispatcher asked, "What is he doing with the bikes?" "
He's just walking with them, holding them both. He's wearing a gray hoodie and black jeans. He's on Maple Street near the corner of Elm. Please hurry."
The call was logged and dispatched to the nearest patrol unit. Officer Brian Collins, who was three blocks away, received the call and turned on his lights. Officer Brian Collins was 38 years old with 9 years on the force, and he had a reputation that his supervisors had documented but never seriously addressed. Over those 9 years, Collins had been the subject of four formal complaints from Black and Latino residents, all of them claiming he had stopped them without cause, questioned them aggressively, and treated them like suspects based on nothing more than their appearance.
All four complaints had been investigated and dismissed with verbal warnings. The pattern was there, written into his file, but no one had ever done anything to stop it. Collins pulled up to Maple Street, and the first thing he saw was Kendrick walking with two bikes. Collins got out of his cruiser, his hand moving immediately to rest on his service weapon, and his voice came out loud and commanding. "
Drop the bikes. Put your hands where I can see them. Now." Kendrick stopped walking and looked up at the officer, confusion crossing his face. "
What? What did I do wrong?" Collins stepped closer, his hand still on his weapon. " I said drop the bikes and put your hands up.
I just got a report of a Black male with two stolen bikes. You match the description perfectly, so I'm not going to ask again. Drop them now." Kendrick's heart started pounding. "