He knew he wouldn't sleep much anyway. The morning had stirred something in him. Not anger, not exactly, but a sharpened focus. The kind that settled into his chest and stayed there until a case broke open. He recognized it the way you recognize an old song.
He hadn't felt it since his last investigation with the federal service, and here it was again. Right on schedule. He sat down at his kitchen table, opened his laptop, and pulled up his case file. The update to Inspector Carol Hampton was routine. Three paragraphs.
Camera positions confirmed. Two additional blind spots identified. No direct suspect contact. He attached his handwritten notes as a scanned document, the way Hampton always preferred, and hit send. Then he sat back and looked at the screen.
He opened a fresh document and started building the timeline. Nine thefts. Four months. He had the incident reports Hampton had forwarded to him before the contract started. Dates, addresses, descriptions of stolen items.
He transferred each one onto a printed neighborhood map, marking each address with a red pen. When he was done, he spread the map flat on the kitchen table and looked at it under the overhead light. The first thing he noticed was the spacing. The thefts weren't random. They weren't scattered across the neighborhood in the careless pattern of an opportunist grabbing whatever they stumbled across.
They were methodical, contained to specific streets, specific clusters of houses. He went back to the incident reports and added the timestamps. Every single theft had occurred between 10:00 in the morning and 2:00 in the afternoon. Every one. On weekdays only.
Not a single weekend incident in four months. Mario circled the time window in red. He sat with that for a moment. 10:00 to 2:00. Weekdays.
That wasn't luck. That was knowledge. Whoever was doing this knew exactly when these specific houses would be empty. Knew the residents' work schedules. Knew when deliveries were expected.
This wasn't a stranger passing through and grabbing an opportunity. This was someone with access to information about this neighborhood's daily rhythms. Mario leaned forward. He opened the Cedarbrook Estates Facebook group on his laptop. Sylvia Peel had made the group public.
Visible to anyone. Members or not. He scrolled back through four months of posts. HOA reminders. Lost pet alerts.
A debate about holiday lights. And then, every Monday morning without exception, a post from Sylvia Peel under the header. Weekly community patrol schedule. Mario went still. He opened the first one.
Sylvia's Monday patrol schedule listed the streets she and two other HOA volunteers would be covering each day of the coming week. Along with the times. It was thorough. Detailed. The kind of post that, on the surface, looked like responsible community organizing.
He opened the second Monday post. Then the third. Then he pulled up his theft timeline and laid it beside the patrol schedule posts. His stomach dropped. The pattern was exact.
Every house that had been robbed was listed in Sylvia's weekly patrol schedules. Specifically in the time windows after Sylvia's volunteer patrol had already passed through. The thief wasn't hitting houses at random during business hours. The thief was hitting houses in the precise gaps that Sylvia's own schedule left uncovered. The windows she had publicly posted every Monday for anyone to read.
Mario sat back slowly. He looked at the map again. Nine red circles. He picked up his pen and drew a line connecting them in chronological order. Then he sat back and looked at where the lines converged, where the center of the pattern sat geographically.
411 Cedar Brook Drive, Sylvia Peel's house. He didn't move for a long moment, just looked at it. Right there in the middle of everything. Not on the edge of the pattern, not near it, at the center of it. Every theft radiated outward from her address like spokes on a wheel.
He thought about what Peachy had told him that morning at the garden fence, the way Sylvia ran the group, the way she controlled the information, the way she always seemed to know exactly what was happening on this block before anyone else did. He thought about Sylvia at her bay window, watching. Always watching. The coffee in his mug had gone cold again. Mario reached over and closed the map.
Then he closed his laptop. He sat in the quiet kitchen for a moment, listening to the house settle around him. Outside, Cedar Brook Drive was dark and still. Every porch light on the block glowing like nothing in the world was wrong. Someone in this neighborhood was robbing their own neighbors blind.
And they had been hiding in plain sight the whole time. The real investigation had just begun. Peachy Washington made good coffee. That was the first thing Mario noticed when she handed him a mug on her front porch Thursday morning. Strong, dark, no nonsense.
He wrapped both hands around it and settled into the wicker chair she'd pulled out for him like she'd been expecting company for years. "I figured you'd come by eventually," she said, settling into the chair beside him. "You've got that look. " "What look is that? " "The one that means you're not done asking questions. " She smiled at him over her own mug. "I taught middle school for 31 years. I know that look very well. " Mario smiled back.
Then, he opened his notepad. He spent Thursday and Friday moving carefully through the neighborhood. He kept it casual, a new resident getting acquainted, learning names, stopping to chat over fences and at mailboxes. He wasn't recording conversations. He wasn't presenting himself as an investigator.
He was just a man being neighborly, asking the kinds of questions new residents ask. "How long have you lived here? Do you know most people on the block? Have you had any trouble lately? " People talked. They always did.
He heard the same things from different mouths. Sylvia Peel ran the HOA group like her personal kingdom. She decided who belonged and who didn't. If she liked you, the neighborhood embraced you. If she didn't, life got quietly complicated.
Noise complaints, pointed comments at HOA meetings, posts in the group that made people look sideways at you without ever saying your name directly. But it was Peachy who gave him the most. They sat on her porch both mornings. She talked and he listened, and he understood within the first hour why Sylvia had tried so hard to silence her. Peachy Washington remembered everything.
Dates, names, specific conversations. She had the memory of a woman who had spent three decades making sure 30 kids a year didn't fall through the cracks. "Two years ago," Peachy said, "on Friday morning, setting her mug down firmly, young family, the Hendersons, moved in on Magnolia Court. You know it, the side street that curves around near the park entrance. " She paused. "Sylvia filed a noise complaint against them the second week they were here.
Then again, the week after that. Then every week for 3 months straight. Did anything come of it? Nothing. Every single time, the responding officer found nothing.
Because there was nothing. Those people were quiet as church mice. " Peachy's jaw tightened. "But it didn't matter. The complaints kept coming and the posts kept appearing in the group. Vague little things, nothing you could point to directly.
But everyone knew who she meant. By month four, the Hendersons were gone. " She looked out at the street. "Nice family. Two little girls. " Mario wrote it down. "Tell me about her finances," he said.
Peachy glanced at him. "You noticed, too? " "Hard not to. " Peachy leaned back. "Her husband, Bert, passed about 2 years ago. Heart attack, sudden. He had money, real estate, some investments.
But from what I understood, it wasn't leave your widow rich forever money. It was comfortable money. Managed carefully money. " She tilted her head. "But about 6 months ago, Sylvia shows up in a brand new car. Then the kitchen renovation starts.
I could hear the contractors from my living room for 3 weeks, and I've seen the shopping bags coming in. Nice ones. The kind with rope handles and tissue paper. All recent. All within the last 6 months," Peachy confirmed.
Mario turned the page in his notepad. Tell me about her brother. Peachy's expression shifted. Something careful moved across her face. Glenn, she said, flat, like the name itself tasted off.
Glenn Peel. Sylvia's younger brother, 28 years old. Moved in after Burt died. Sylvia said it was so she wouldn't be alone in the house. Peachy paused.
He keeps to himself. Doesn't work, far as I can tell. Sleeps late. I see his car, beat-up gray thing, leaving mid-morning sometimes, back by early afternoon. Mario's pen stopped moving.
Mid-morning. Back by early afternoon. 10:00 to 2:00. He kept his face neutral. You ever have any direct problems with him?