Attorney Dana Whitcomb met them in a small office above a tax-preparation business. She was in her forties, wore glasses on a cord and had a habit of examining a document before examining the person who handed it to her. After watching the unedited footage, she said Grant might have a viable complaint about the slap, and the bar might have a strong defense regarding its right to refuse service and eject an abusive patron. Both matters needed careful treatment. She would not promise that a jury would admire Mara's reaction, nor would she pretend that one mistake erased everything preceding it.
Dana recommended three immediate actions. They should preserve the original recordings with metadata, provide them to the investigating deputy and contact the liability insurer. They should also write separate witness accounts before memories changed through repetition. She would address any demand letter and discourage the business from offering money for silence. Mara listened with a sense of relief that had nothing to do with certainty. At last someone was describing a difficult problem in steps small enough to complete.
Dana read the purchase agreement next. Its buyer was an entity named Valley Meridian Properties, which had been formed only three months earlier. The managers listed in its filing were a corporate services company, and the mailing address led to a law office in Sacramento. That alone was not suspicious, Dana said, but the agreement's urgency and unusual liability waivers deserved attention. She asked why a purchaser interested in a bar needed to close before the county's next planning session, and nobody in the room could answer.
Mara told her about Victor Hale's remarks in the parking lot. Dana asked for the video and watched his reference to the sale twice. Then she wrote down the exact words and underlined the date. She advised Evelyn not to sign any revised agreement until a separate real-estate attorney reviewed the transaction. Evelyn hesitated. The offer could disappear, and she did not have the energy for another year running the saloon. Dana told her the choice was hers, but a buyer who wanted a signature before she could understand the papers was not making the choice easier for her.
That afternoon Walter arrived at the attorney's office with Caroline, who had taken a day off to make certain he kept his medical appointment. He wore a clean work shirt instead of his vest and looked smaller without the familiar leather. Dana greeted him respectfully and asked what he had witnessed. Walter described Grant's insults and the movements in the room, but when he reached the moment Mara struck him, he stopped for a second and asked her to repeat the question. He remembered the event accurately after a pause, though Mara could see Caroline watching him.
Outside, Walter told Mara he resented being treated as fragile. Mara said nobody was asking him to become somebody else. She was asking him to keep himself well enough to remain part of their lives. He stared across the parking lot for a long time and then admitted that he sometimes