The room went still. Then Dean Sloan rose again. " This is defamatory. " Judge Whitaker's eyes moved to her. " Dean Sloan, " he said.
One more interruption and I will have you removed from this courtroom. The gallery froze. Sloan sat down. Slowly, Maya could feel the shift now. Not belief, not yet, but attention.
Real attention. The kind Charlotte had assumed belonged to her. Mia reached for the next section. There is also a deeper issue with the case problem itself. Charlotte gave a short, bitter laugh.
Of course, there is. Mia turned slightly toward her. The fictional transfer document in this competition appears to be modeled on a real case from Alabama involving a woman named Evelyn Price. At that name, Professor Carter looked down. She had known it was coming.
Maya continued, "Mrs. Price lost her home after signing a transfer document under pressure from a real estate company. In the original record, there was a sworn statement that the notary was not present when the document was signed. That statement was not included in the competition appendix. She lifted another paper. This is a copy of that sworn statement.
A murmur moved through the gallery and the law firm representing the real estate company in that matter was connected to Miss Whitmore's father. Charlotte shot to her feet. That is a lie. Maya faced the judges again. The document speaks for itself.
Judge Whitaker extended one hand toward the clerk. The paper moved forward. Dean Sloan's face had gone still in a way that no longer looked calm, Maya reached for the final stack in that section. And when I refused to withdraw quietly, Dean Sloan produced a private medical record belonging to my mother, Ruth William, a night nurse in Birmingham, and threatened to use a minor procedural note to create a negligence scandal that could cost my mother her license and pension. The courtroom changed, not in volume.
In temperature. Ruth's name seemed to sit in the air with more force than any citation. Maya handed up the photograph of the hospital document and her written account of the meeting. My mother was not part of this competition. She was not part of this dispute.
Her name was used to frighten me into silence. Judge Whitaker took the document himself this time. He read it slowly. Charlotte leaned toward Trevor and whispered something harsh. Trevor shook his head.
Barely. Maya saw it. She was close now. Too close for them to remain composed. She looked at the judges, then at the room.
Your honor, if being from a small school makes my evidence invisible, then she never finished the sentence. Enough, Miss William. Bang. Judge Samuel Whitaker's hand came down on the bench so hard that every person in the courtroom flinched. Maya stopped mid-sentence.
The sound seemed to hang in the air long after his palm left the wood. A sharp final crack that cut through whispers, objections, breathing, and every polished lie that had been floating in that room since morning. Judge Whitaker rose from his chair. He did not rise slowly. He stood with force.
His eyes were fixed on Maya. " Enough, Miss William, " he shouted. " Sit down and be silent for one full second. " Maya did not understand what had happened. Her hand was still on the edge of the podium.