“Those are unrelated matters.”
“They involve the same car, the same location, and your approval,” Nathaniel said. “They're related enough to be preserved.”
After the meeting Alma Price walked beside Nathaniel to the parking lot. She was seventy-four, Black, a retired school principal with silver hair and a habit of looking directly at people while they spoke. Her husband had died five years earlier. She had lived in Marlowe Commons from the first construction phase and retained a quiet authority no board vote could give or remove.
“Caroline has always enjoyed deciding who belongs where,” Alma said. “But this feels worse.”
Nathaniel unlocked his truck. “It is worse. Somebody is trying to turn my son's injury into a story about dangerous residents.”
Alma nodded. “I have something you should see.”
She took him to her kitchen and opened a laptop. Her security camera faced the side lane behind her house, which ran toward the recreation hall's maintenance entrance. On the evening Duncan claimed the Aston Martin was vandalized, a flatbed transporter had entered the lane carrying the intact-looking car. Two hours later it departed with the same vehicle, now partially covered by a protective sheet. The angle could not prove the side panel condition, but the timing contradicted Duncan's account that the car had remained undisturbed in a marked recreation space until he found the damage the following morning.
Alma had saved the file before the system overwrote it. She handed Nathaniel a copy and insisted he send it to the investigating detective without editing.
“People think age makes us slow,” she said. “Sometimes it just means we know when to keep receipts.”
Nathaniel smiled despite the anger in his chest. “I could use somebody like you on every investigation.”
“I'm retired from managing fools professionally,” she replied. “But I still take occasional consultations.”
The detective assigned to the vehicle complaint was Rosa Calder, a county investigator in her forties whose demeanor suggested a lifetime of refusing to be impressed by costly objects. She contacted Nathaniel after receiving the footage and thanked him for sending it through the evidence portal rather than appearing unannounced at the station.
“I understand you have an official position,” she said. “For this investigation, you're a witness and an interested party. That's all.”
“That's exactly what I want,” he replied.
Calder traced the Aston Martin's movements through a combination of toll-camera records, commercial building footage, and interviews with Duncan's employees. What she found did not resemble vandalism. The vehicle had been damaged inside the detailing shop several days before the recreation event. An employee named Javier Montes had witnessed the supply trailer strike its side and reported it to Duncan, who told him not to create paperwork until the owner returned. Javier had made a note in the shop's shared task system anyway, then watched it disappear from the visible schedule.
When Calder asked for a copy of the original task log, Duncan claimed the computer had crashed.
That was his second major mistake.