The first thing Evelyn Hartley noticed about the richest rancher in Wyoming Territory was that he was hiding pain. The second was that someone had cut the leather strap on his saddle. She saw both things within a minute of stepping down from her father's wagon, and neither belonged in the conversation her sisters had rehearsed for two hundred miles. Lydia was smoothing the lace at her throat, Beatrice was practicing a dazzling smile, and their father was reminding them that marriage to Gideon Mercer could save the family farm. Evelyn was staring at a frayed strip of leather hanging from the saddle outside the barn, wondering why a man with so many hired hands had nobody watching his back.

Gideon stood on the porch of Black Creek Ranch with one hand braced against a post. He was thirty-four, dark-haired, handsome in a severe, tired way, and dressed more like a working cattleman than the wealthy owner of eighty thousand acres. His left knee bent stiffly when he came down the steps, and a narrow scar crossed his jaw. Lydia offered her hand as if presenting it to a prince, and Beatrice greeted him with a clever remark about the size of his empire. When Evelyn approached, she said, "You shouldn't ride that bay horse until someone replaces the saddle strap."
Her father made a strangled noise. Gideon looked past her toward the barn, where his favorite bay gelding stood tethered beside a post. "Why?" he asked. Evelyn showed him the leather, its cut almost hidden beneath the buckle, and he rubbed the smooth edge with his thumb. A strap worn through by use would have been ragged; this one had been sliced cleanly, then bent to make the damage look old.
"You think somebody did it deliberately?" he asked. "I think somebody hoped you wouldn't notice," Evelyn answered. For the first time that evening, the rancher's expression changed from polite resignation to interest. He told the stable boy to remove the saddle and invited the family inside without another word about it.
The Ardens had come from a struggling homestead outside Laramie, carrying three daughters and a proposal that was almost an auction. Their father, Samuel, had borrowed money after two failed harvests and believed a marriage into the Mercer fortune would settle his debts. Gideon had agreed to meet the sisters because Samuel once saved his father's life during a winter crossing. He had promised a fair hearing, not a bride, and had made it clear that no woman would be expected to accept him merely because her father needed help.
Lydia, twenty-six, was lovely, accomplished, and accustomed to being admired. Beatrice, twenty-four, read newspapers from Denver, argued politics with traveling salesmen, and wanted a life larger than the farm. Evelyn, twenty-two, had spent more years balancing household accounts and nursing sick animals than attending dances. She had soft brown hair, gray-green eyes, and the sort of quiet beauty people noticed only after she stopped speaking.