describe himself as a harmless old man who had never made a mistake. He explained that the motorcycle belonged to him, that Clayton refused repeated requests to get off, and that he grabbed the younger man to remove him from the seat. He admitted he wished he had handled the moment differently. Then he described the flashlight and the kicks.
"You threw the first man to the ground, correct?" the attorney asked.
"I pulled him off my motorcycle. He fell."
"You understood that doing so might start a fight?"
"I understood he was damaging my property and had been told to stop. I didn't expect three men to beat me after I was down."
"You're an experienced fighter, aren't you?"
Walter looked at the jury. "I'm an older man who made one quick decision and paid for it. The person who paid the most wasn't me."
The judge told him to answer the question rather than make speeches. Walter apologized. Lena appreciated the correction. A witness did not become more truthful by trying to win the room with a memorable line. When he stepped down, he looked exhausted. Diane guided him to a chair, and he took her hand openly in front of the gallery.
Lena testified the following afternoon. She placed her feet flat on the floor and kept her eyes on the prosecutor when the questions began. She described the meal, the truck, the scratched motorcycle, Walter falling, and her decision to cover him. The prosecutor asked why she ran forward. She answered that the men kept kicking him after he could no longer fight back. She had believed he might die. She knew she was smaller and unlikely to stop them, but she hoped that seeing another person between them and their target would make them leave. It had not worked immediately. She remembered pain, rain, and the moment one of the men shouted about Walter's vest.
The defense questioned her living situation. Did she have a stable address at the time? Had she ever been arrested? Had she used drugs? Lena answered each question without embellishment. She had been homeless, had received a trespass warning for sleeping near a closed business, and had never been convicted of a crime. She had not been intoxicated on the night of the assault. The attorney suggested that she might have been eager to win favor with Walter because he offered her food. She looked at him for a moment before replying.
"I was hungry," she said. "He fed me. I didn't think that meant he owed me anything. When they hurt him, I thought it was wrong."
The attorney asked whether she expected the jury to believe she put herself in danger for a man she had known less than an hour. Lena said yes. The attorney repeated the question with a trace of disbelief. She answered again, this time more firmly. "I knew what being left alone felt like. I didn't want him to be alone." There was a pause before the next question. Nobody applauded. The courtroom was not a theater. Yet Lena saw one juror lower her eyes to the notebook in her lap and remain there for several seconds.