Behind them, 41 motorcycles waited in the afternoon heat, patient and still. The way things wait when they understand that something important is in the process of being decided. The Harley sat between all of them, damaged and present and entirely itself, carrying every mile it had ever traveled, and every pair of hands that had ever worked on it, and every conversation that had ever happened beside it, on the side of a highway somewhere in the American Southwest, carrying Jack Callahan's decades and Mia's 11 hours in the specific terrible weight of the afternoon, carrying all of it, the way a machine carries things silently, without complaint, waiting for whoever was going to do the work of deciding what happened next. Officer Diane Reyes had been doing this job long enough to know that the moment a crowd shows up, the truth gets complicated. Not because people lie, though they do, but because everyone who was there believes they saw the most important part and nobody saw all of it.
And sorting out what actually happened from what people felt happened was the kind of work that took patience and a very good notebook. She had three pages already and she hadn't finished with the first witness. Paty from the diner was giving her account in the way that certain women of a specific age disposition give accounts thoroughly in chronological order with editorial commentary woven in at intervals that made it clear she was not simply reporting facts but delivering a verdict. The tall one with the tank top started it. Paty said he was the one who pointed at the bike first and and said something to the others.
I couldn't hear the words, but I could see his face, and that was a face that had already decided something. The kind of face my late husband wore every time he was about to do something he knew he'd regret and was going to do anyway. A Reyes wrote that down without comment. The young one, the blonde one, he was the last to touch the bike, Paty continued. And even then, he looked like someone who was doing something because the group expected it, not because he wanted to.
You can tell the difference. You know, after 30 years of watching people in a diner, you can tell the difference between someone who wants to do something and someone who's doing it because stopping feels harder than going along. Reyes looked up from her notebook. Can you tell me what he used on the seat? His car keys, Paty said flatly.
He had them in his right hand. He looked at the seat for a moment first and I thought I actually thought he was going to stop. He hesitated and then the tall one called something to him and he went ahead and did it. She paused. I should have come out sooner.
I saw what was happening and I went for the phone to call you all instead of coming straight out and I've been sitting with that since it happened. You did the right thing. Reyes said I did the safe thing. Paty said, "They're not always the same. " Reyes closed her notebook for a moment and looked at the parking lot where Mia was standing with Raymond Cortez and two of the other riders and where the four young men were positioned in a loose formation of supervised uncertainty near the second cruiser.
Garza had their IDs. The phones were going to be the crux of it. Specifically, the video on the filmmaker's phone, which Garza had confirmed was still running when they arrived, meaning the camera had caught not just the destruction, but the aftermath, including Mia's words, Ray's arrival, all of it. That was either going to be a problem for the defense or a gift for the prosecution, depending on how the rest of the afternoon went. She walked back toward Mia.
I need to talk to you about the valuation, Reyes said. The way this is going to go depends significantly on what we establish about the bikes worth before today. Criminal damage in this state runs on a tiered system. If the damage exceeds a certain threshold, we're looking at felony level charges rather than misdemeanor, and that changes the entire picture for all four of them. Mia was quiet for a moment, not hesitating processing.
Reyes had noticed that about her in the parking lot. She didn't react quickly. She let things settle before she spoke, which was either a sign of very good emotional regulation or very deep feeling or in this case probably both. The bike was insured and appraised 18 months ago when I completed the restoration. Mia said, "Collector status, full documentation. "