Then came the more successful sections. Beneath several rows of older trees, the orchard floor held less loose litter and certain accessible pest observations were lower than in similar untreated areas. Sophie had helped collect samples without knowing which blocks were which, and Owen showed Meredith the method rather than claiming the comparisons were perfect. Preston asked whether differences in shade and moisture could explain some of the result. Owen said they could, which was why the family had left the uncertain observations out of its financial calculation. The co-op manager looked up from her notes. "What did you count instead?" she asked.
Owen opened the thick notebook to the pages he had prepared at home. He showed the cost of acquiring the birds, feed, fencing, shelter repairs, water equipment, labor, predator losses, and the forty-three hens no longer in the flock. He did not rush past the ugly figures. Then he showed the egg receipts, the reduced cleanup time in successful sections, savings from changes in how the orchard handled fallen material, and the family labor that had been shifted rather than eliminated. Finally he showed the revised professional crop-protection budget and explained that it had been chosen according to monitoring and need. He was careful not to credit every dollar of that reduction to the birds themselves.
"So the chickens didn't replace my program," Preston said. "No," Owen answered. "They couldn't have. We still need to watch the trees, and we still have to treat problems when the evidence says to." Preston looked pleased by the admission until Owen turned the page. "But the experiment made us price the whole system instead of buying decisions one at a time. The hens helped with some jobs, cost too much on others, and made us examine where money was actually going. When you add the changes we can support with receipts, the smaller treatment plan and the orchard work fit our operating cash without a new twelve-thousand-dollar loan."
Preston took the notebook and examined the columns. He asked why Owen valued family labor instead of calling it free. Owen told him Elise would not permit that kind of accounting. Preston almost smiled. He asked why one number had been crossed out, and Owen explained that an early insect count had been biased by the way he selected samples. He asked whether Owen knew the birds would continue providing the same benefit next year. Owen said no, and that another season might show smaller savings or none at all. Meredith watched the consultant's expression change from skepticism to concentration. It was the first time she had seen him read the boy's notes without looking for a joke.
Nathan had been standing a little apart, listening as he might listen to a mechanic explain a repair he had commissioned. When Preston reached the final sheet, Nathan spoke. "It doesn't make us rich," he said. "It doesn't even guarantee a good harvest. But we aren't signing a loan just because we're scared of not signing one." Preston closed the notebook and looked across the rows. "You still need professional monitoring," he told them. Nathan agreed and reminded him that they had already hired it in a limited form. Preston handed the book back to Owen. "Well," he said after a pause, "you've certainly done more work than I expected."