That night Ethan and Laura argued at the kitchen sink while Frank pretended to repair a lamp in the next room. Laura said there was nothing irresponsible about accepting a good offer for a speculative object. Ethan accused her of wanting to surrender before they had finished looking. The accusation hurt her enough that she stopped washing dishes and set the sponge down. She told him he had no right to speak as though she did not understand unfinished work.
She had been keeping their household running since his father's death, carrying responsibilities that did not become smaller because she was tired. Ethan apologized, but the apology did not immediately mend the damage. He went to his room and thought about how easily the pleasure of solving a mystery had allowed him to overlook his mother's real concerns. At breakfast he came downstairs with a proposal instead of a protest. They could set a firm date for an independent inspection.
If the cabinet had no unusual contents or significance, they would review Gordon's offer on its actual merits. They would not borrow against a possible treasure or spend money they did not have. Frank approved the plan because it gave uncertainty a boundary. Laura agreed on the condition that any specialist's fees be disclosed before work began, and that nothing be sold without confirming exactly what the auction terms transferred. Ethan also offered to use his next earnings from weekend chores toward the furnace repair.
His mother told him that being a son did not require rescuing her financially, but she accepted the gesture as evidence that he was listening. Gordon returned two days later and found that the family had decided to seek an appraisal. He tried a different tone. Rather than mock the boy, he warned them that publicity could attract dishonest buyers, expensive lawyers, and disappointed relatives. Some of those warnings were reasonable.
He said an expert might charge more than the cabinet was worth, which could also be true. But he would not identify the collector supposedly interested in an anonymous old cabinet, and he resisted when Frank suggested documenting the reason for the increased offer. Gordon left without signing anything. Ethan watched his truck disappear and understood that the man might know something useful, but he also might simply be gambling on an object he wanted cheaply. The only way forward was independent verification. claiming he was making a generous exception because of Frank's reputation.
Laura, who had been worrying about household expenses, thought the proposal deserved serious consideration. $4,000 could repair several problems around their home and still leave Ethan with money for school. For the first time, Ethan and his mother disagreed openly. Laura reminded him that nobody had confirmed the chest contained anything important. Ethan understood her reasoning, but he could not ignore the historical evidence he had uncovered.
Frank suggested waiting until a qualified specialist examined the cabinet. They agreed not to sell it immediately. Gordon left visibly frustrated, and Ethan wondered whether refusing the offer would become the second costly mistake of his adventure. Later that week, an email arrived from Dr. Catherine Rowe, a historian specializing in mechanical timekeeping.