"Hadn't seen this copy in years."
"I found his vest too."
Mason nodded once, as though this confirmed something he had always suspected.
Cody swallowed. "Did my father kill your brother?"
Mason looked up.
The question hung between them with a cruelty Cody had not intended but could not take back.
"Your father spent twenty-five years asking the wrong question," Mason said.
"What's the right one?"
Mason turned toward the room, leaving the door open. Cody followed after a moment. On the bed sat the metal box, open now. Mason picked up the old flood article and tapped a photograph showing several children wrapped in blankets.
"How many kids went home because he stayed?" Mason asked.
Cody stared at him.
"Earl made a bad tie in freezing water with half a bus screaming behind him," Mason continued. "Tommy saw it. Tommy went back. That's true. Know what else is true? Earl went back too. He went under twice trying to reach my brother. We had to drag him out before the river took two men instead of one."
"He blamed himself."
"Every day, far as I could tell."
"Did you blame him?"
Mason's jaw tightened. "For a while I blamed everybody. The bus driver. The county. The storm. Earl. Tommy for going back. Myself for not stopping him. You can spend a lifetime dividing one bad minute into smaller pieces, trying to find the piece that would've changed everything."
"But you didn't hate him?"
"No."
Cody looked down at the metal box. "Then why didn't he know that?"
Mason had no easy answer. He sat on the edge of the bed, older suddenly than he had looked at the bar. "Because men get stupid about pain. We think if we don't say it, we're carrying it better."
Cody saw the cassette tape in the box. "What's that?"
Mason picked it up. "Your father sent it to me fourteen years ago."
"You listened to it?"
"Part of it. Tape deck quit halfway through. Never found another one. Never tried very hard."
"Why bring it here?"
Mason glanced at Earl's name on the list. "Because I was supposed to listen with him."
Cody stared at the tape for several seconds. "Ruth has an old cassette player in the storage room at the bar. She uses it when the radio goes out."
Mason gave him a look that said he knew exactly what returning to The Rusted Spur would mean.
"You don't have to come back for Brett," Cody said. "I'll handle him."
"I'm not coming for Brett."