He lawyered up and stayed silent and was charged anyway because Decker's account and the financial records were sufficient without him. He was arraigned in December in the case against him was by Andrea Marsh's assessment airtight. Walter Bennett received a settlement offer from Meridian's insurance entity in January that was three times the amount he'd been paid for his land. He did not accept it immediately. He sat with it for 3 weeks called Ethan every 2 days and finally accepted it not because the money restored what he'd lost it couldn't, but because it was the clearest acknowledgement available in the language of law and money that what had happened to him had been wrong.
The acknowledgement mattered. He told Ethan that the acknowledgement mattered more than the amount. Ruth Garza received a comparable offer. She accepted it in the same week as Walter and used part of it to fund a community legal clinic in the county seat that would help property owners understand their rights in future infrastructure acquisition processes. She told the local paper it was the most useful thing she could think to do with money that represented something painful.
And the local paper ran her photograph on the front page and Ethan cut it out and kept it on the refrigerator. Carol Whitfield's screenshot became one of the central pieces of evidence in the federal prosecution. Her attorney successfully argued that she had preserved it in good faith under genuine uncertainty about its significance and that its admissibility was unimpeachable. She sat in the federal courthouse in Helena in February and watched the evidence presented that she had carried on her phone for 14 months. and she told Ethan afterward that she had cried in the bathroom and then come back out and watched every remaining minute of the proceedings because she was not going to miss a second of it. Dennis Pruittt's property was never touched again after the night his dogs had run Decker's people off for the second time.
His testimony about the visits and the intimidation pattern was part of the prosecution's documentation of the systematic escalation that Cascade had used across multiple properties. He kept his land. He expanded his fence line in the spring and got two more dogs, which he named after federal agents he'd come to respect during the process. A fact he shared with Solless directly, who responded with an email that was the warmest and least professional communication she had sent in her entire federal career. Grant Holloway was convicted on nine of 11 counts in the spring.
The federal sentencing guidelines for the category of offenses he was convicted of were significant. His attorneys appealed immediately and the appeal process would take additional months, but the conviction itself was solid built on Decker's testimony. Carol Whitfield screenshot the financial records. Robert Hail's cooperation in the video evidence recovered from the phone that showed with absolute clarity Paul Decker instructing his people to pour fuel across Ethan Walker's barn while Ethan was grabbed and held and forced to watch. That recording, the thing they had taken to break him, the image they had wanted to use as leverage, it put Grant Holloway in front of a federal judge.