Naomi did not know about those conversations. She had been busy arranging school pickup, training Biscuit, and trying to restore the ordinary rhythm of work. Yet Vincent's situation returned to her life when a lawyer for the prosecution asked whether she and Isaiah would cooperate with a more formal interview. Naomi was willing to describe what she saw and what she heard. She was less willing to subject Isaiah to repeated questioning. She consulted an independent family advocate, who explained procedures for minimizing stress when a young child might be a witness. The prosecutor agreed to seek available recordings and adult testimony first, reserving further child interviews for matters that genuinely required them.
It was not an easy compromise. Naomi wanted the people responsible held accountable, but she also understood that an investigation could consume a family while everyone involved claimed to be acting for the greater good. She asked whether Isaiah's first statement was preserved. It was. She asked whether she could receive advance notice of any additional requests. She could. Most important, she asked that no one tell her son he had a duty to be brave again. The advocate wrote that request down, and Naomi felt something in her chest loosen.
Christmas approached without much of the peace people advertised on television. Naomi decorated their apartment with paper stars Isaiah had cut at school. Biscuit stole one ornament and carried it proudly beneath the kitchen table. The hospital staff organized a modest holiday collection for families facing financial strain, and Naomi contributed what she could. She still received messages from strangers who wanted to reward Isaiah, but she declined most offers. A few anonymous donations arrived through the community shelter, which used them to expand its low-cost puppy classes. That seemed to Naomi an appropriate result: other families could care for animals without turning one little boy into a public attraction.
On Christmas Eve, Isaiah placed a drawing of Biscuit beneath Thomas's photograph. The puppy was depicted wearing a firefighter helmet, and a tiny man in the corner held a red leash. Naomi asked who the man was. "Daddy," Isaiah said. "He can hold the leash in my picture." Naomi put her arm around him. They watched snow begin to gather on the windowsill, and for a while neither of them spoke. Some absences were too large for cheerful words, but small rituals could make room for them without demanding that they go away.
Vincent spent Christmas morning alone. Claire had sent a photograph of Lucy holding the frog birthday card, along with a message saying the child liked the picture. It was the first photograph she had sent directly to him in nine years. He printed it, then placed it in a drawer instead of displaying it for visitors. The picture was not proof that he had been forgiven. It was evidence of a small door that Claire had chosen not to close. He respected it by leaving it alone until she decided to open it farther.
In January, a storm knocked out power across part of Naomi's neighborhood. The apartment grew cold, and Biscuit became fascinated by the flashlight beam Isaiah cast along the wall. Naomi checked their supplies and learned the building's backup arrangements were less reliable than the landlord had claimed. She contacted a neighbor who used an electrically powered medical device and helped arrange assistance through the city's emergency support line. Thomas had always taught her that community preparedness mattered, but she had never possessed the time or money to organize much beyond her own front door.