“Doing what?”
“Buying remounts for freight outfits. Sometimes horses.”
Ada leaned forward. “Did Eleanor ever have trouble with him?”
Thomas looked toward the window.
“Once.”
“What kind?”
“He tried to buy Nightbird. Eleanor refused.”
“When?”
“A month before she died.”
Ada said nothing.
Thomas’s voice sharpened. “Don’t build a murder out of a frightened horse.”
“I’m not.”
“You’re thinking it.”
“I’m thinking someone tied a rope around your mare hard enough to burn her chest.”
Thomas stood.
“And what do you want me to do with that?”
“Remember everything you stopped looking at because grief gave you an easier answer.”
He went pale with anger.
“You have no right.”
“No,” Ada said quietly. “But you asked Nightbird to carry the blame for three years. Maybe somebody should ask whether it belonged to her.”
Thomas ordered her out of the office.
For two days, he barely spoke to her.
On the third, he found Ada in the tack room holding Eleanor’s old saddle.
“I told Gideon to burn that,” he said.
“He didn’t.”
Ada turned the saddle over.
One stirrup leather had been replaced. The other was original and scarred near the buckle.
“Look.”
Thomas came closer.
Along the underside of the saddle skirt was a deep diagonal cut.
Not wear.
A knife cut.
Ada pointed to the rigging strap. “If somebody sliced this almost through, it might hold until weight shifted hard.”
Thomas touched the cut with one finger.
His face changed.
“When we found her, the saddle was under Nightbird’s belly.”
“Yes.”
“I thought the cinch broke when she fell.”
“Maybe it did.”
He looked at Ada.
“Maybe somebody made sure it would.”
The possibility tore open the ranch.
Thomas rode to the territorial sheriff in Johnson County. The sheriff listened but said three years was a long time, the saddle proved little, and Warren Slade had never been formally accused of anything. Still, he agreed to ask questions.
Gideon remembered a detail he had never thought important: two strangers had been seen near the north ridge the week Eleanor died. One wore a gray coat with silver buttons.
Caleb remembered something worse.
He had been eight, watching from the porch the morning his mother rode out.
“There was a man at the gate,” he said.
Thomas knelt in front of him. “What man?”
“I don’t know. Mama told me to go inside.”
“What did he look like?”
Caleb squeezed his eyes shut.
“He had something shiny in his hand.”
“A gun?” Thomas asked.
The boy shook his head.
“A handle.”
Ada felt cold move down her back.
Thomas did not say Warren Slade’s name.
He did not need to.
The next morning, someone opened Nightbird’s corral gate before dawn.