One afternoon, a cattle buyer named Warren Slade arrived with two men from Cheyenne. Slade was loud, prosperous, and carried a silver-handled quirt he tapped against his boot when he talked. Thomas disliked him but needed his business. A brutal winter the year before had cut the Broken Spur herd by nearly a quarter, and the ranch’s note at the territorial bank was coming due in January.
Slade saw Nightbird in the corral.
“That the widow-maker?” he asked.
Thomas’s expression went cold. “Don’t call her that.”
Slade laughed. “Heard your wife broke her neck off that one.”
Before Thomas could answer, Nightbird saw the silver handle of the quirt.
She exploded.
The mare slammed backward into the fence, spun, and crashed shoulder-first into a post. Ada ran toward her.
“Put that down!”
Slade looked at the quirt. “This?”
“Put it down.”
Instead, he slapped it against his palm.
Nightbird screamed.
Thomas moved so quickly that Slade barely had time to react. He seized the quirt, ripped it from the buyer’s hand, and threw it into the mud.
“Get off my land.”
Slade stared at him. “You’ll lose my contract.”
“Then I’ll lose it.”
“You owe the bank more than you can cover without my purchase.”
Thomas stepped closer. “Get. Off. My land.”
Slade left furious.
Nightbird stood pressed into the corner of the corral, shaking.
Ada looked at the discarded quirt.
Its handle was silver, but the lash itself was black braided rawhide.
The same kind Gideon said Eleanor had carried the morning she died.
That evening, Thomas poured two fingers of whiskey but did not drink them.
Ada stood across from him in the office.
“Who was with Eleanor the day she died?”
“No one.”
“Who knew she was riding north?”
He frowned. “Everyone. She checked the north cattle every Thursday.”
“Did Warren Slade know?”
Thomas stared at her.
“Why?”
“Nightbird reacted to his quirt before he used it.”
“That doesn’t mean anything.”
“Maybe not.”
“He was living in Cheyenne then.”
“Doing what?”
“Buying remounts for freight outfits. Sometimes horses.”
Ada leaned forward. “Did Eleanor ever have trouble with him?”
Thomas looked toward the window.
“Once.”
“What kind?”
“He tried to buy Nightbird. Eleanor refused.”
“When?”
“A month before she died.”
Ada said nothing.
Thomas’s voice sharpened. “Don’t build a murder out of a frightened horse.”
“I’m not.”
“You’re thinking it.”
“I’m thinking someone tied a rope around your mare hard enough to burn her chest.”
Thomas stood.
“And what do you want me to do with that?”
“Remember everything you stopped looking at because grief gave you an easier answer.”
He went pale with anger.
“You have no right.”
“No,” Ada said quietly. “But you asked Nightbird to carry the blame for three years. Maybe somebody should ask whether it belonged to her.”
Thomas ordered her out of the office.
For two days, he barely spoke to her.
On the third, he found Ada in the tack room holding Eleanor’s old saddle.
“I told Gideon to burn that,” he said.
“He didn’t.”
Ada turned the saddle over.
One stirrup leather had been replaced. The other was original and scarred near the buckle.
“Look.”
Thomas came closer.