The town hall was strung with lanterns, and the fiddlers were playing a lively tune. Wyatt stood in the corner, leaning against a support beam, looking agonizingly handsome and suitably tortured. A crowd of women hovered at the edge of his personal space, waiting for him to ask one of them to dance. Suddenly, the heavy wooden doors of the hall swung open. A stranger walked in, a man covered in trail dust with a vicious scar cutting across his left cheek.
He looked around the room, his eyes scanning the crowd until they landed on Wyatt. From across the room, Joe saw Wyatt's reaction. The brooding, stoic hero didn't stand taller. He didn't square his shoulders, he flinched. It was a microscopic movement, but Joe caught it.
Real visceral panic flashed in Wyatt's eyes. He quickly pulled his hat down lower, turned away, and slipped out the side door into the dark alley before the stranger could fully register his face. Joe abandoned her punch glass and slipped out the front door, circling around the building. She crept along the side of the town hall, pressing her back against the rough pine boards. In the shadows of the alley, she could hear Wyatt breathing heavily.
A moment later, the stranger walked into the alley. "I know you're here, Dalton." The stranger hissed into the darkness. "Dalton," Joe thought, her breath hitching. "You got one week," the stranger said to the shadows.
"The boss wants his cut of the Denver stage money, or he's coming for you, and he's bringing the law with him." The stranger spat into the dirt, turned, and walked away. Joe waited until the heavy footsteps faded before stepping out into the moonlight. Wyatt was pressed against the brick wall of the neighboring bank, his face pale, the romantic, mysterious aura entirely stripped away. He looked terrified.
He looked weak. He saw Joe and froze. He immediately tried to recover, straightening his posture and adopting that familiar world-weary scowl. "Miss Mercer, you shouldn't be out in the dark." "And you shouldn't be hiding in an alley, Mr. Callahan.
Or should I call you Dalton?" Joe asked, her voice cold and steady. Wyatt stepped forward, trying to use his physical size to intimidate her. A trick that worked on every other woman in town. "You heard things you don't understand, Joe.
It's a dangerous world. I have a troubled past." "Stop it," Joe snapped, refusing to step back. "Don't try that dime-novel nonsense on me. You're no tragic hero.
You're a thief and a coward." "You don't know me," he growled. "I know exactly what you are," she fired back. You've spent the last four months letting the women of this town feed you, clothe you, and fawn over you because you knew they'd provide the perfect cover. No one suspects the handsome, grieving widower of being a stagecoach robber on the run.
The silence between them was deafening, broken only by the muffled fiddle music bleeding through the walls of the town hall. The next morning, the town square was bustling after church services. Abigail Reed was standing by the fountain, regaling a group of women with a story about how Wyatt had supposedly rescued a stray calf from a ravine. "He is a man of such profound depth," Abigail sighed, clutching her parasol. "A true gentleman of the West.