Clara set the photograph beside the plate. "You kept the station alive without them for eight years," she said. "That counts for something." Elias answered that he had managed it because the stage company paid regularly and because other men were willing to work long hours for fair wages. Clara glanced toward the half-open office door. "Then perhaps the station was never as solitary an accomplishment as you imagined." He considered that and recognized the kindness hidden in her bluntness. She was not diminishing his work. She was allowing him to stop believing that needing help meant failure.
The next morning he visited Ruth with his accounts under his arm. It was not easy to ask someone who had lost business because of him for advice, but she listened. He wanted to know whether a weekly freight route could truly bring enough money to keep the stable operating through winter. Ruth asked what his fixed costs were. He named feed, labor, fuel, repairs, taxes, and interest. She took a pencil and added them herself, questioning each sum. They found that the station's lodging rooms were losing money unless customers paid an honest rate and that the stable could survive if he reduced the number of idle horses before snow came.
"Sell two horses," Ruth said, "not the good team Clara hires. Use the money to clear your oldest feed bill, then stop borrowing to pretend you've still got a stage contract." Elias hated the clarity of the advice. He asked whether she would consider giving Clara the Copper Ridge orders again if the chance arose. Ruth gave him a look that reminded him of his mother. "I'll give her work when she's the right driver for it and when the wagon's right for the load. That's how business ought to work."
Clara had begun thinking about another problem. The customers along the northern road did not know when she would be passing, and some feared that if they gave her money for an order she might disappear before returning. That distrust was reasonable in a territory where traveling peddlers could vanish over a ridge and never be seen again. She asked Ruth to let her post a small delivery schedule beside the store's front door, with her rates and the conditions under which weather might delay service. Ruth agreed on the condition that every customer receive a receipt. Clara wrote a simple form in her careful hand and asked Elias to check its arithmetic. He corrected one total, then returned the page without altering her terms.
The first schedule named Thursday for the northern farms and Monday for the Copper Ridge road, provided the crossing was passable. Clara promised no more than she could control. A ranch family could leave an order at the store, or send word through a traveler stopping at Cottonwood. Payment would be due on delivery except for special purchases that required a deposit, and Clara would not accept unsecured cash beyond what her business could cover. The rules seemed fussy to the stable hands, who were accustomed to men agreeing on a fee with a handshake. Ruth said the rules were what allowed a handshake to remain honorable when memory failed.