On July 22nd, 1998, a Thursday morning just after 9:00, Mustafa Eren pulled his Case IH 5130 into the dealer lot in Polatlı and understood with absolute clarity that 2 weeks was not a measure of time, but a measure of everything he was about to lose. He was 67 years old. The tractor was 6 years old. The wheat in his fields was 8 days from optimal harvest moisture. A hydraulic pump that controlled the header lift on his combine attachment had failed that morning during a test run. Without it, he couldn't raise or lower the header. Without the header functioning, he couldn't harvest. 
The dealer service manager, a man named Vedat who'd worked there since 1991, came out to meet him. Mustafa explained the problem. Vedat listened, walked around the tractor, asked a few questions about symptoms, and said he'd need to get it into the shop to confirm. Mustafa said he'd wait. Vedat said it might take an hour. Mustafa said that was fine. He sat in the waiting area with a cup of tea that had gone cold by the time Vedat came back.
Vedat's face told him the answer before the words did. The hydraulic pump had catastrophically failed. Internal seals were destroyed. Metal fragments were in the fluid. The pump couldn't be rebuilt. It had to be replaced. Mustafa asked how long. Vedat said 2 weeks, maybe 3. The part had to come from Italy. There was no stock in Turkey. Mustafa asked if there was any way to expedite it. Vedat said he could try, but express shipping would cost as much as the part itself, and even then it would still take 7 to 10 days minimum.
Mustafa sat very still. He asked one question. He asked if Vedat was certain there were no alternatives, no compatible parts from other models, no temporary solutions, nothing that could get him through the next 10 days. Vedat said no. This pump was specific to the 5130's hydraulic system. No substitutes would work safely. Mustafa nodded. He stood up. He thanked Vedat and walked out to his truck. He did not argue. He did not ask to speak to the owner. He did not raise his voice. He simply left.
Miss it by 3 days and you lost yield to shattering. Miss it by a week and you lost quality to weather. Miss it by 2 weeks and you lost the crop entirely. His father missed a harvest once in 1947 when the landowner's equipment broke down and couldn't be repaired in time. They lost 40% of the crop to an early rain. The landowner deducted the loss from their share. Mustafa's family ate less that winter. He remembered his father saying that owning your own equipment meant owning your own timing. It meant you didn't wait for someone else's machine to be fixed. You didn't wait for someone else's schedule. Mustafa believed that.
When he bought his first 60 hectares in 1956, he saved for 3 more years to buy a used tractor outright. No debt, no dependency. By 1982, he owned 400 hectares. He'd bought his first Case IH tractor, a 956, in 1982 from the Polatlı dealer. Not because it was the cheapest, not because it was the most powerful, but because the dealer had parts in stock and service capacity during harvest season. That availability mattered more than brand loyalty or sales discounts.
Mustafa had built his entire relationship with Case IH on one principle. When he needed them, they were ready. For 16 years, that principle held. In 1985, a belt tensioner broke on the 956 during wheat harvest. He called the dealer at 7:00 in the morning. They had the part. He picked it up by 9:00. He was back in the field by 11:00. In 1990, an electrical issue caused starting problems on his newer Case IH 1255. He brought it in on a Wednesday. They diagnosed it Thursday morning. They had the part. It was fixed by Thursday afternoon.
In 1994, he bought the Case IH 5130, his largest investment yet at $38,000. It came with a 2-year warranty and a dealer promise. Critical parts would be kept in stock during harvest season. For the first 4 years, that promise held. When he needed filters, they had them. When he needed hydraulic hoses, they had them. When he needed a fuel injector in 1996, they had it. The relationship worked because both sides understood the stakes. Mustafa paid full price. He didn't negotiate aggressively. He didn't shop around for cheaper parts elsewhere. In return, the dealer kept inventory that ensured he never waited more than a day or two for anything critical. That was the unspoken contract.
Until July 22nd, 1998, when Vedat told him 2 weeks and offered no alternative. Mustafa sat in his truck in the dealer parking lot for 10 minutes before starting the engine. He was doing math. 8 days until optimal harvest. Maybe 10 if the weather held. 2 weeks minimum for the part. Even if it arrived in exactly 14 days, he'd be a week late. A week late in late July in Central Anatolia where afternoon temperatures hit 38° and thunderstorms could roll in without warning. A week late meant the wheat would be overdried. The kernels would be brittle. Combine loss would increase. Test weight would drop. The buyers would downgrade his wheat or reject it outright.
He calculated the loss. 400 hectares. Average yield 3 tons per hectare. 1,200 tons total. If he lost 20% to harvest timing issues, that was 240 tons. At current prices, roughly $70,000. The hydraulic pump cost $1,800. Express shipping might add another 1,800. Even if he paid $3,600 and got the part in 7 days, he'd still be cutting it close. But Vedat had said 7 to 10 days minimum. That meant 10 was more likely. That meant he'd definitely be late. That meant the $70,000 loss was not theoretical. It was inevitable.
He started the truck. He drove home. His wife saw his face and asked what happened. He told her. She asked what he was going to do. He said he didn't know yet, but he was already thinking about something he'd never seriously considered before. Switching brands entirely. Not because Case IH equipment was bad. The 5130 had been reliable for 4 years. The failure wasn't a design flaw. It was just a part wearing out. These things happened. But the dealer's response, 2 weeks, no alternatives, nothing we can do, had revealed something Mustafa couldn't ignore. The availability he'd counted on for 16 years was gone.
Friday morning, July 23rd, he called a John Deere dealer in Ankara. He'd never done business with them. He knew them only by reputation. He asked to speak to someone about purchasing a tractor. The salesman who answered, a man named Cem, asked what he was looking for. Mustafa said he wasn't sure yet. He said he had a Case IH 5130 that was down for repairs and he needed to know what his options were. Cem asked what was wrong with it. Mustafa explained. Cem asked when he needed to harvest. Mustafa said 8 days.
Cem was quiet for a moment. Then he said they had a John Deere 6400 with low hours on their lot right now. Demo unit. Available for immediate sale or short-term rental. It had compatible hydraulics for standard combine headers. If Mustafa wanted to rent it to get through harvest, they could arrange that tomorrow. If he wanted to buy it, they could finalize paperwork within 2 days. Mustafa asked about parts availability. Cem said they kept critical harvest season parts in stock at their Ankara warehouse. Hydraulic pumps, belts, filters, injectors. Lead time for non-stock parts was typically 1 week from their European supplier, sometimes less.
Mustafa asked if that was a guarantee. Cem said no, but it was their standard practice. He said in 12 years at the dealership, he'd never had a customer wait more than 10 days for a part during harvest season. Mustafa thanked him and said he'd think about it. He didn't sleep that night. He sat at the kitchen table with his financial records. He listed every piece of Case IH equipment he owned. The 5130, a 4230 from 1988, a 1255 from 1990, 956 from 1982 that he kept for light field work. He listed the implements that were Case IH specific. The combine header, the planter. He calculated trade-in values. He calculated what it would cost to replace everything with John Deere equipment. The number was staggering. Close to $90,000 even with trade-ins.
It would require financing. It would require a multi-year commitment to a brand he'd never used. It would require abandoning 16 years of familiarity, parts inventory, and service relationships. It was irrational. But losing $70,000 to a 2-week parts delay was also irrational. And between two irrational choices, Mustafa chose the one that gave him control over timing. Friday morning, July 23rd, he called Cem back. He said he wanted to rent the John Deere 6400 for 2 weeks. Cem said they could have it ready by that afternoon. Mustafa drove to Ankara. He signed the rental agreement. The cost was $1,200 for 2 weeks including delivery and pickup. Expensive, but irrelevant compared to losing the harvest.
The tractor was delivered to his farm Saturday morning. Mustafa spent Saturday afternoon familiarizing himself with the controls. They were different from the Case IH. The hydraulic response was different. The turning radius was different. But by Sunday, he had it figured out. He started harvesting Monday, July 27th, 5 days after the hydraulic pump failure. 3 days ahead of optimal timing, which gave him buffer. The John Deere 6400 ran flawlessly. No breakdowns, no delays. He finished harvesting all 400 hectares in 6 days. The wheat quality was excellent. Test weight was premium grade. He sold the entire crop for full market price. No losses, no downgrades. The rental had saved him $70,000.
But something else had happened during those 6 days. Mustafa had operated a John Deere tractor for the first time, and it worked. It wasn't better than the Case IH. It wasn't worse. It was just different. And the fact that it was available when he needed it, not in 2 weeks, not eventually, but immediately, had changed his calculation about what mattered most in equipment ownership. On August 4th, the day after he finished harvest, Mustafa called Cem again. He said he wanted to talk about buying the 6400. Cem said it was still available. Mustafa said he also wanted to talk about trading in his Case IH equipment. Cem said he'd need to see the equipment to make an offer, but they could work something out. Mustafa invited him to the farm. Cem came the next day with an appraiser. They spent 3 hours looking at the four Case IH tractors. They checked hours, condition, maintenance records. Cem made an offer, $42,000 total for all four tractors. Mustafa said that was low. Cem said it was fair market value for used equipment that was 10 to 16 years old. He said if Mustafa wanted to sell them privately, he might get more, but it would take time. Mustafa said he'd think about it.
He called the Polatlı Case IH dealer that afternoon. He asked to speak to the owner, a man named Taner. Taner came to the phone. Mustafa explained that he was considering selling his Case IH equipment and wanted to know if the dealer would be interested in taking them on trade. Taner asked why he was selling. Mustafa said he'd lost confidence in parts availability. Taner was quiet for a moment. Then he said he understood Mustafa was frustrated about the hydraulic pump delay, but that was an exceptional situation. It wouldn't normally take that long. Mustafa said he couldn't afford exceptional situations during harvest. Taner said he appreciated that, but switching brands seemed extreme. He said the 5130 was a good tractor. Once the pump was replaced, it would run for years. Mustafa said the pump was irrelevant now. He'd already harvested with a rental. Taner asked what Mustafa wanted him to do. Mustafa said he wanted to know if the dealer would match or beat the John Deere trade-in offer. Taner asked what the offer was. Mustafa told him. Taner said he couldn't match it. He said trade-ins were tight right now. He could offer $38,000 for all four tractors. Mustafa said that was 4,000 less than John Deere. Taner said he couldn't go higher. Mustafa thanked him and hung up. He called Cem back that evening. He said he'd take the offer. $42,000 for the Case IH tractors. He wanted to buy the John Deere 6400 and look at other models to replace the rest of his fleet. Cem said they could start paperwork immediately.
Within 3 days, Mustafa had sold all four of his Case IH tractors to the John Deere dealer, purchased the 6400, and placed orders for two additional John Deere tractors, a 6200 and a 5400. Total cost after trade-ins was $61,000. He financed 40,000 over 5 years. It was the largest debt he'd taken on since buying his land in the 1970s. But he didn't hesitate. The decision had been made in the Polatlı dealer parking lot 5 days earlier when Vedat had said 2 weeks and offered nothing else.
The hydraulic pump for the Case IH 5130 arrived at the Polatlı dealer on August 11th, 1998. Exactly 20 days after it was ordered. Vedat called Mustafa to let him know. Mustafa said he'd already sold the tractor. Vedat was silent. Then he said he was sorry it had worked out that way. Mustafa said he was, too. Vedat asked if there was anything the dealer could have done differently. Mustafa said yes, they could have kept the part in stock. Vedat said they couldn't stock every part for every model. Mustafa said he understood, but he couldn't farm with a 2-week buffer for critical failures. Vedat said that was fair. They ended the call.
The hydraulic pump sat in the parts department for 6 months before it was returned to the supplier for credit. Other farmers in the region heard what Mustafa had done. Some thought it was smart. Some thought it was reckless. A neighbor named Ramazan, who also farmed wheat and used Case IH equipment, said Mustafa had overreacted. He said parts delays happened with every brand. He said switching to John Deere wouldn't eliminate the problem. Mustafa said maybe not, but John Deere had been ready when he needed them. Case IH hadn't. Ramazan said that was one data point. Mustafa said it was the only data point that mattered.
Another farmer, a younger man named Bulent, who was just starting out, asked Mustafa if he recommended John Deere. Mustafa said he didn't know yet. He'd only had the equipment for a few weeks. But he said if Bulent valued availability over everything else, John Deere was worth considering. Bulent asked what Mustafa valued. Mustafa said he valued not waiting. He valued knowing that when something broke, it could be fixed in days, not weeks. He valued control over timing. Bulent bought a John Deere tractor 6 months later. He told Mustafa it was because of that conversation.
The John Deere 6400 ran without issues for 8 years. Mustafa put over 6,000 hours on it. It needed repairs occasionally, a starter motor in 2001, a clutch in 2003, hydraulic hoses in 2005, but every part was available within 3 days. The longest he ever waited for a John Deere part was 6 days for a transmission seal in 2004. That was during off-season. It didn't affect any planning or harvest timeline. The dealer kept their promise, not perfectly, but consistently enough that Mustafa never regretted the switch.
In 2006, Mustafa turned 75. He started scaling back. He leased 200 of his 400 hectares to a younger farmer. He kept the other 200 and continued working them himself with help from seasonal labor. The John Deere tractors were aging now. The 6400 had over 8,000 hours. The 6200 had over 7,000. Both were still functional, but maintenance costs were increasing. Mustafa considered upgrading. The John Deere dealer offered him trade-in values. The numbers were fair, but Mustafa decided to keep the tractors a few more years. They still worked. That was enough.
In 2009, the 6400 had a hydraulic pump failure. The same type of failure that had started everything 11 years earlier on the Case IH 5130. Mustafa called the John Deere dealer at 8:00 in the morning. They checked inventory. They had the pump in stock. He picked it up that afternoon. He installed it himself with help from a mechanic. The tractor was running again by the next morning. Total downtime was 18 hours. Total cost was $2,100. Mustafa thought about July 1998. He thought about Vedat saying 2 weeks. He thought about the $70,000 he would have lost if he'd waited. He thought about the $90,000 he'd spent switching brands. Even 11 years later, he believed he'd made the right choice.
In 2011, Mustafa stopped farming entirely. He was 80. His health was declining. He leased out the remaining 200 hectares and sold the John Deere tractors. The 6400 sold for $8,000. The 6200 sold for 7,000. The 5400 sold for 5,000. 20,000 total. He'd paid 61,000 for them in 1998. 13 years of depreciation. The math made sense. He didn't lose money. He didn't make money. The tractors had served their purpose.
His son, who was 53 and worked as an accountant in Ankara, helped him settle the equipment sales. The son asked if his father ever regretted leaving Case IH. Mustafa said no. The son said it seemed like a drastic decision based on one part's delay. Mustafa said it wasn't about the delay. It was about what the delay revealed. The son didn't understand. Mustafa explained. He said for 16 years he'd believed that if he was loyal to the dealer, paid full price, didn't haggle, came back consistently, they would prioritize his needs when it mattered. But when it mattered most, they'd offered him 2 weeks and no alternatives. That revealed the relationship wasn't what he thought it was.
The son said maybe they just didn't have the part. Mustafa said that was exactly the problem. They should have had it. Or they should have had a backup plan. Or they should have been honest years earlier that parts availability was no longer guaranteed during harvest season. Instead, they had let him believe everything was fine until the moment it wasn't. The son said that seemed harsh. Mustafa said farming didn't allow for harshness or fairness. It only allowed for timing. And 2 weeks was bad timing.
Mustafa Eren died in September 2019. He was 88. The land he'd farmed for 63 years was still leased. His son kept the lease agreements in place for another year, then sold the land in 2020 to a farming cooperative. The money went into his inheritance. The son had no connection to farming. He didn't know what his father's Case IH tractors had looked like. He didn't know what the John Deere 6400 had sounded like. He knew only that his father had switched brands once, quickly, and had never looked back. He didn't know why.
When he found his father's financial records from 1998, he saw the rental agreement for the 6400, the trade-in receipts for the Case IH equipment, and the financing documents for the new John Deere tractors, all dated within 5 days. August 4th through August 9th, 1998. The son thought it was strange that someone would make such a large decision so quickly. He didn't understand that the decision had already been made on July 22nd in a dealer parking lot, when his father had heard 2 weeks and understood what it meant.
The Polatlı Case IH dealer is still in operation. Taner retired in 2015. New ownership took over. Vedat left in 2003 to work for a different dealer in Konya. The dealership doesn't remember Mustafa Eren. They don't remember the hydraulic pump delay in July 1998. It was one repair among thousands, one customer among hundreds. They never knew that losing Mustafa cost them not just his future business, but the business of farmers like Bulent, who made decisions based on Mustafa's experience. They never knew because Mustafa didn't complain publicly. He didn't write negative reviews. He didn't tell other farmers to avoid them. He just quietly sold his equipment and moved on.
Ramazan, the neighbor who'd said Mustafa overreacted, stayed with Case IH. He had parts delays occasionally. Once in 2002, he waited 16 days for a transmission part during off-season. Once in 2007, he waited 11 days for an electrical component. Neither delay affected his harvest timing. He never had a reason to switch brands. He farmed successfully until 2016, then retired. When people mention Mustafa's decision, Ramazan says it was unnecessary. He says 2 weeks wasn't that long. He says Mustafa could have worked around it. Maybe he's right. Maybe Mustafa could have waited, harvested late, taken the quality downgrade, and absorbed the loss. Maybe the loss wouldn't have been as bad as Mustafa calculated. But Mustafa didn't take that risk. He chose certainty over loyalty. He chose availability over history. And he paid $90,000 to never wait 2 weeks again.
The Case IH 5130 that started everything was sold by the John Deere dealer to a farmer in Kırıkkale in September 1998. That farmer installed the delayed hydraulic pump that had finally arrived. The tractor ran well for 7 more years. It changed hands twice after that. The last owner used it until 2014, then sold it for parts. The hydraulic pump that had cost Mustafa his 16-year relationship with Case IH lasted longer than his loyalty had.
Mustafa Eren's decision to sell everything in 3 days wasn't impulsive. It was the result of a calculation that weighed 67 years of farming experience against one dealer's inability to meet a harvest deadline. The calculation was simple. 2 weeks was too long. Not because 2 weeks was objectively unreasonable, but because 2 weeks at that specific moment in late July with wheat at optimal moisture and weather uncertainty looming was the difference between success and failure. The dealer didn't understand that, or they understood but couldn't do anything about it. Either way, the relationship ended. Not with anger, not with argument, just with Mustafa walking out of the parking lot, calling another dealer, and beginning the process of erasing Case IH from his operation entirely. It took 3 days to decide. It took 13 years to prove he'd been right. And it took 21 years until his death for the question to finally stop mattering.