it entered processing. Recoverable components were separated according to plant capabilities and product specifications. Some proceeds were distributed through direct sales calculations, while others flowed through netback values after transportation, fuel, processing, and contractual deductions. Gideon followed the presentation with a pencil, sometimes stopping Nora to ask her to explain a word as though she were talking to a cattleman rather than another accountant. She never seemed offended.
The session answered one important question. The plant had recovered helium during periods relevant to JC-9's production. It did not prove that every helium molecule from Gideon's ranch became a separate item sold under his name. Instead, the accounting system allocated plant-level product revenues and costs to eligible streams according to contract formulas and quality measurements. Elias explained that the critical issue was whether JC-9's volume and composition had been included in those allocations and whether the lessor's royalty was calculated on the correct contractual basis. For the first time, Gideon saw why a statement could omit the word helium while still including some associated value. He also saw why he needed the actual HM-517 terms before accepting any assertion that the account was correct.
When the agreement was finally produced under the court's confidentiality order, Elias spent a week working through its schedules. HM-517 covered transportation and processing arrangements involving multiple streams, quality adjustments, and downstream products. It contained a formula for allocating revenue after specified deductions. Some charges were permissible under the agreement; others depended on how the underlying lease treated royalty value. Marian warned Gideon that a private processing contract between commercial parties could not automatically rewrite the lessor's rights under the older lease. The legal and accounting questions had to be examined together. A number that was correct for the operator's internal settlement might not necessarily be the number owed to a particular mineral owner.
The examination found that JC-9 was assigned a share of recoverable helium-related product value through the facility's allocation system. It also found an accounting discrepancy in how certain deductions had been carried from the processing schedule into the royalty statements for a limited period. Elias traced the discrepancy to a change in the plant's reporting software that had not been reconciled across every account. The issue was technical, not evidence of a conspiracy to steal helium. Canyon Star agreed to review the affected calculations and revise them where necessary. Gideon felt a surprising relief at that finding. He wanted the math to tell the truth, even where the truth was less dramatic than the story people were beginning to tell about his ranch.
A second finding mattered more to his immediate case. Payments associated with Gideon's conveyed mineral interest had continued to be recorded under High Mesa after the sale. The operator had not been formally notified at closing, and some early disbursements followed the existing payee instruction before Gideon submitted his documents. Later amounts had been held or delayed while title was reviewed. Whether the bank actually received and retained particular amounts required tracing checks, deposits, adjustments, and suspense entries by date. Marian insisted on an accounting rather than treating a payee label as proof that every expected dollar had changed hands. Gideon approved. His father had once told him to count the cattle in the trailer, not the shadows moving beside it.