They met with an agricultural attorney named Ellis Carver in a county-seat office above a hardware store. Carver was a former farm lender who spoke plainly about notes, secured transactions, and the limits of a borrower's negotiating strength. He reviewed the bank correspondence, the development map, and Mara's photographs, then asked a question that made Walter straighten. Had anybody documented the drainage channel before construction began? Walter described older maps, his maintenance records, and photographs taken after ordinary spring storms. Carver told him those materials might be far more important than whether Sutter's tone had sounded threatening.
The attorney brought in an independent hydrologist, Dr. Priya Chen, who had spent two decades studying agricultural drainage in the Delta. Priya refused to treat the flooding as proof of a conspiracy. She asked for rainfall records, historical elevation surveys, drainage-district files, permit drawings, construction inspection reports, and photographs from before the development site was cleared. She also wanted to know whether anyone else had experienced changed water levels. Mara collected everything she had, while Walter drove to three neighboring farms to ask if their ditches had behaved differently since construction began.
One neighbor, a widower named Curtis Lang, reported that the west drainage channel had been unusually dry after moderate rain even while Walter's low ground flooded. Another produced photographs of construction trucks hauling fill near a culvert that had previously carried runoff away from Haskins Farm. A third remembered a contractor asking to cross his property with grading equipment and leaving when he refused. None could say whether the developer had intended harm. But together their accounts gave Priya a starting point for reconstructing the movement of water rather than relying on the appearance of the flooded field alone.
Priya spent ten days surveying the area, checking ditch invert elevations and comparing the work on the ground with authorized drawings. She discovered that the permitted plan had called for a wider detention area and a controlled discharge away from the Haskins boundary. The built outlet was smaller, more concentrated, and directed toward the narrowest low point on Walter's property. The design and the construction did not match in a way that appeared capable of changing both the volume and direction of water entering the old ditch. She wrote that the alteration substantially increased repeated inundation of the lower acreage under rainfall conditions that previously produced only temporary ponding.
Carver cautioned Walter about the language. The report supported causation: a change in physical works, followed by a measurable change in drainage. It did not establish which person had approved the change, whether the change violated a particular legal duty, or whether somebody had designed it to force a sale. Those questions required documents and testimony beyond the hydrologist's scope. Walter admitted that he wanted somebody to say Sutter had deliberately flooded the farm. Carver answered that wanting a clear villain was understandable but an incomplete claim was easier to defeat than a carefully supported one.