Teachers Asked a Quiet Girl to Play Violin as a Joke — Then She Said, 'I'll Do It'

Chapter 1

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The first time the teachers laughed at Amara Ellis's violin, the girl did not cry. She sat in the last row of a crowded eighth-grade classroom in Toledo, Ohio, with her hands folded over a scratched black case and watched two adults turn a private part of her life into a joke. Forty other children were watching, and several had already lifted their phones. Coach Russell Mercer, who had been assigned to organize the spring talent showcase because he was the loudest person on the faculty, grinned when the math teacher pointed at Amara. Mrs. Valerie Kline had found an audience, and an audience usually made her careless.

"What about our famous little violin player?" Mrs. Kline said, stretching famous until it sounded like its opposite. "She's dragged that old thing to school all year. Perhaps she can show us what it actually does." A boy near the windows made a noise like a cat fighting in an alley. Someone else pulled his lips tight and pretended to drag an invisible bow across his throat. Mercer laughed with the class, although he could have ended the moment by saying one kind sentence. "Come on, Ellis. Put your name down. If you're carrying it, let's hear it."

Amara's fingers rested against the worn handle of the case. The instrument inside had a nick near the lower edge and a repaired seam that she knew by touch even in the dark. Her grandfather's initials were scratched beneath the chin rest, where nobody would see them unless the violin was taken apart. There were plenty of things about her life that her classmates could laugh at, including her faded shoes and her mother's old sedan, but the violin was different. She had brought it to school because there was no safe place to leave it at home on days when the apartment maintenance crew worked inside. She had kept it close because her grandfather had entrusted it to her, and because it had become the one language in which she never felt interrupted.

Mrs. Kline folded her arms, delighted by the uncomfortable silence. "We're only having fun, sweetheart. Don't look so serious." The word sweetheart landed harder than the laughter. It suggested that Amara was a little girl who needed an adult to explain her own humiliation to her. She remembered the way her mother looked after a supervisor had described an unpaid extra shift as a favor. The same small smile, the same demand that the person being mistreated pretend it was nothing. Amara looked from the teacher to the clipboard on the desk beside Coach Mercer.

"I'll play," she said.

A laugh broke off in the middle of the room. Mercer looked at her with the startled expression of someone whose harmless joke had suddenly acquired consequences. Mrs. Kline narrowed her eyes slightly. "Really, Amara? The whole school will be there." Amara held her gaze just long enough to let the question reveal itself, then stood and wrote her name on the sixteenth line of the performance list. Her handwriting was small and steady. Under the heading TYPE OF ACT, she wrote Original violin composition. She placed the clipboard back on the desk, picked up her case, and sat down without another word.

News in the same category

Teachers Asked a Quiet Girl to Play Violin as a Joke — Then She Said, 'I'll Do It'

30 Part