Teacher Forced a Little Girl to Play Piano as Punishment — Then Her First Notes Stopped the Laughter

Chapter 19

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Rachel began taking a greater interest in how she herself played. She told her private instructor that she wanted to understand phrasing rather than only prepare for examinations. Her instructor, a lively woman named Patricia Bennett, was delighted and suggested that Rachel listen to recordings of many pianists performing the same piece. Rachel discovered that two musicians could follow the written notes faithfully and still sound completely different. The discovery reduced the pressure to be the one correct person in every room.

When Timothy suggested a piano-and-violin duet, Nora agreed to try. At their first rehearsal he rushed through the opening and she stopped him, then immediately apologized. He laughed and said he wanted her to stop him when he rushed because his mother did not know anything about music and only shouted from the kitchen that he should slow down. They worked for twenty minutes without arguing about who would lead. By the end they had settled on a passage in which the violin seemed to ask a question and the piano answered.

Rafael visited one rehearsal and left without interrupting. He was pleased by the way the children listened to one another but more relieved that Nora was no longer playing only when an adult put her under pressure. He had learned that help could become control very quickly when a child was called talented. His job was to give her access and keep choices open, not to turn her into the school's favorite story about overcoming difficulty.

The first person to suggest that Nora should perform a solo at the spring concert was not Mrs. Caldwell but Timothy. He had listened to their duet rehearsal and thought the audience deserved to hear her alone as well. He mentioned it to Rafael while the principal was checking the rehearsal schedule. Rafael thanked him and said Nora would decide for herself. He then asked Nora privately whether a solo was something she wished to consider and told her it was equally acceptable to say no.

Nora wanted to think about it. Part of her longed to play on a stage again, where the piano could be heard without the anxious shuffling of a classroom. Another part remembered the last recital Elena had attended, when her mother wore a blue scarf because her hair had begun to thin from treatment. Nora had reached the final page of her piece, looked out, and seen Elena smiling from the second row with tears running down her face. The idea of returning to a stage without her made Nora feel as though she might be leaving Elena behind.

Grace encouraged her to talk about the fear rather than practice through it. She suggested they could choose a short piece, invite only a small audience at first, and stop without apology if the emotions became too much. Nora asked if other musicians ever became frightened of pieces that reminded them of people. Grace answered that many did, and that music did not demand they confront every memory at once. She also said there was nothing wrong with deciding that a piece belonged to private life rather than public performance.

News in the same category

Teacher Forced a Little Girl to Play Piano as Punishment — Then Her First Notes Stopped the Laughter

50 Part