Mrs. Whitcomb had taught music for nineteen years. She had organized concerts, won local teaching awards, and developed students who later joined respected youth ensembles. Most parents regarded her as demanding but effective. Over time, however, she had begun confusing children who resembled her most successful students with children who had the greatest capacity to learn. Well-dressed pupils with private lessons received her attention easily. Quiet students without professional instruments at home were often assigned the simpler parts before they had a chance to show what they could do.
On Evelyn's first day, Mrs. Whitcomb mispronounced Wu as though it were a longer, unfamiliar word, then waved away the correction. The class laughed because the teacher's tone invited them to laugh. Evelyn stared at her notebook and counted the number of lines on the staff printed across the page. She thought about her mother patiently teaching audiences to say the names of composers from many languages. The memory stung. She did not speak again during attendance.
Six weeks remained before the spring concert, and Mrs. Whitcomb had already formed a nearly complete program. Nathan Reed, who had studied violin for six years, would perform a solo. Claire Benton, a capable pianist whose parents supplied the school with recital sponsorships, expected the major keyboard feature. A cheerful trumpet player named Owen would lead a short brass ensemble. Evelyn listened to the announcements without resentment. She wanted nothing that would force her to explain why her own name had never appeared on the list.
Claire was less patient. She had been playing piano since kindergarten, and her mother had invested time and money in making sure she could perform confidently. Claire had a beautiful technique for her age, with precise scales and careful phrasing, but her greatest fear was being ordinary. At home, every recital was followed by a conversation about what she should improve next. Praise arrived with conditions attached. When she noticed Evelyn watching the grand piano, she interpreted the look as envy rather than longing.
Two weeks after enrolling, Evelyn stayed behind in the music room because she had misplaced a workbook. She found it beneath a chair, but by then the last group had gone into the hallway. For several seconds she stood alone with the grand piano. The lid was closed, and the afternoon light stretched across the keys. She approached it the way she might approach an old friend she feared would no longer recognize her.
She did not sit. She pressed middle C with one finger, and the note rang into the empty classroom. The sound was round and unmistakably real, with overtones that no paper keyboard could reproduce. Evelyn closed her eyes and saw her mother seated beside her, counting softly in the old apartment. She removed her finger at once. The memory was beautiful and unbearable, and she hurried out before she could begin to cry. She did not see Mrs. Whitcomb standing near the supply cupboard, watching with narrowed eyes.