The meeting lasted almost two hours. No one mentioned the date promise until they were leaving. Jack asked whether she considered this coffee part of her public wager. Caroline looked horrified. He smiled and said he was teasing her, but he added that he wanted any future meeting to be something both chose freely. Caroline said she wanted that too. As they parted, she asked whether Ellie might like to visit a small automobile museum on his next trip. Jack said he would ask his daughter rather than answer for her. Caroline accepted that without hesitation.
On the flight home Jack caught himself smiling at a detail from the conversation. Caroline had described Arthur's habit of sharpening pencils with a pocketknife because he distrusted the electric sharpener in his office. Jack's father had done the same thing. Such small points of resemblance were not evidence that two people belonged together, but they made the world feel less divided between the wealthy gallery upstairs and the working people at the loading dock. Jack wondered whether Caroline had felt the same thing. He decided not to ask. Not yet.
The most difficult evidence against Richard Halden did not arrive in the form of a secret recording or a dramatic confession. It came from a project schedule kept by a woman named Marianne Bell, who had worked in Sterling Heritage's purchasing office for twenty-seven years. Marianne maintained her own spreadsheet because the corporate system regularly overwrote projected completion dates when management approved new revisions. She had watched the same unfinished work appear as nearly complete through four consecutive quarters, and she was tired of being asked to explain delays that her records already explained.
Caroline met Marianne in a cramped office beside the warehouse. The purchasing manager brought three binders and placed them on the table without ceremony. She explained that qualified subcontractors had repeatedly warned Sterling Heritage about shortages of specialized machine work. The warnings had reached Richard's oversight committee. Rather than authorize additional resources or renegotiate deadlines, the committee had approved summaries that shifted delivery dates forward while describing the projects as proceeding normally. Some of those decisions had been made before Caroline became chief executive.
"I am not saying every delay was avoidable," Marianne told her. "Historic restoration is uncertain by nature. But there is a difference between discovering an unexpected defect and pretending the defect has already been solved." Caroline asked whether Marianne had raised the concerns through the formal reporting chain. She had. Two managers left the company. A third told her to stop making everything sound worse than it was. Marianne held up a page of dated correspondence and said that she had kept the original because memory could become strangely unreliable when a problem reached the boardroom.