The FBI opened a civil rights investigation immediately. Walker's former supervisor made sure of it. This wasn't just a local police matter anymore. This was a federal case. The FBI reviewed the body camera footage. They reviewed the witness videos. They interviewed all 12 bystanders. They pulled Walker's medical records with his permission.
The medical records were clear. Walker had both legs amputated below the knee following an IED explosion in Afghanistan. The injury was permanent. There was no question about his disability. The VA had rated him fully disabled. He'd been receiving benefits for years. He had prosthetic legs custommade for his specific needs.
Federal prosecutors charged Reynolds with three crimes. Civil rights violation, assault on a disabled person, and battery. all federal charges. Reynolds hired a lawyer through the police union. The lawyer told him to stay quiet, but the evidence was overwhelming. The trial started months later. It lasted 3 weeks.
The prosecution's case was straightforward. They played the body camera footage. They called all 12 witnesses. Every single one told the same story. Reynolds ignored Walker's explanations. He dismissed the VA card. He refused to call a supervisor. and he used physical force on a man who'd clearly stated he was disabled.
Walker testified for two hours. He described his military service. He talked about losing his legs. He explained his FBI career. Then he described the assault. He talked about the pain of hitting the concrete, the humiliation of being disbelieved despite showing proof. The fear that Reynolds might hurt him worse.
Walker's testimony was calm. He didn't raise his voice. He just told the truth. The defense tried to argue that Reynolds made an error in judgment. They said he had no malicious intent. He was just trying to enforce the law. He thought Walker was committing fraud. The prosecution tore that argument apart.
Reynolds had visible evidence, the disabled veteran plate, the VA identification card, Walker's clear statements, and Reynolds ignored all of it. Then he used force. That wasn't an error. That was a choice. The jury watched the body camera footage multiple times. They heard from eight bystanders during the trial.