Then Ethan’s former mother-in-law, Patricia Morgan, arrived without warning. Patricia had never approved of the move to Maple Hollow, believing Lily should live closer to her maternal grandparents in Columbus. She found Claire in Ethan’s kitchen one morning wearing his sweatshirt and immediately decided that the new neighbor was the reason her granddaughter had been acting withdrawn. “Rebecca has been gone barely a year and a half,” Patricia said coldly. “And you’re already playing house with someone else?” Ethan stepped between them. “You don’t get to speak to Claire that way.”
Patricia’s anger came from grief, but it did not make her words less cruel. She accused Ethan of neglecting Lily, pointed to the missed school concert, and announced that she had spoken to an attorney about requesting a formal grandparent visitation schedule. “Lily needs stability,” she insisted. “Not a stranger moving into her mother’s place.” Claire felt as if she had been slapped. She quietly left through the back door while Ethan argued with Patricia, refusing to let Lily hear the conversation.
The next day, a neighborhood gossip page posted a photograph of Claire leaving Ethan’s house at dawn. The caption suggested that the single father had been neglecting his child while entertaining his attractive neighbor, and comments quickly filled with speculation. Claire recognized the photograph as having been taken from the sidewalk near Patricia’s car, but she had no proof who had submitted it. A local client called to ask whether she was involved in a scandal, and a parent at school questioned Lily about “Daddy’s new girlfriend.” By the end of the week, Lily had heard enough whispers to ask the question Ethan had been dreading.
“Are you going to make me call Miss Claire Mommy?” she asked. Ethan felt the air leave his lungs. “No, sweetheart. Nobody is going to make you call anyone Mommy.” Lily stared at the stuffed rabbit in her lap. “Grandma says people forget when they get new families.” Ethan sat beside her and took her small hand. “I will never forget your mom,” he said. “And you never have to choose between loving her and liking someone else.”
Lily nodded, but the uncertainty remained in her face. When Claire came over that evening, Lily stayed in her bedroom instead of running to greet her. Claire understood immediately that something had changed, and the realization hurt more than the gossip. She told Ethan she needed a few days to think. He agreed, though he looked as if she had asked him to surrender something precious.
The distance might have healed if not for the letter that arrived the following Monday. Claire had been offered a six-month illustration residency in Seattle, complete with a studio, an advance, and a chance to develop her own picture-book series. She had applied months before she and Ethan became close, and she had almost forgotten about it. The offer was everything she had worked toward, but the acceptance deadline was ten days away. She read the letter twice, then sat in her kitchen looking through the window at the pink bicycle next door.