Nate's hand came up to cover hers, pressing her touch more firmly against his face. "I don't deserve you." he said quietly. "Let me be the judge of that." They stood there in the cold, two broken people finding something unexpected in each other.
Not love, not yet, but the possibility of love, the hope of it. And for now, that was enough. They reached Butte the following evening, exhausted and frozen, but determined. It took only a few hours of asking at boarding houses to find Martha Griggs. She was a small woman, older than the sketch had suggested with hunched shoulders and frightened eyes.
When Clara and Nate appeared at her door, she tried to close it in their faces. Nate caught the door with one hand. "Mrs. Griggs, we just want to talk." "I don't know anything." the woman said, her voice shaking. "I don't know anything about anything." "You visited my husband."
Clara stepped forward, her voice steady despite the rage turning in her chest. "Thomas Brennan." "You came to our shop, pretended to be collecting for the church." "A few weeks later, he was dead." Martha's face went white. "I didn't I never We're not here to hurt you."
Clara forced herself to speak gently. "We're here to understand what happened." "If someone made you do something, told you it was harmless, we need to know." The woman's eyes darted between them, terrified. "They'll kill me."
she whispered. "If I talk, they'll kill me." "Who?" Nate's voice was hard. "Who will kill you?" "The The Thorntons."
The name came out like a curse. "Mrs. Thornton and that son of hers, they made me do it. They said it was just medicine. They said it would help the man sleep. I didn't know. I swear I didn't know."
Clara felt her knees buckle. Nate caught her, held her upright. "What did they give you? His voice was ice. What did you put in his food? Martha was crying now, tears streaming down her weathered face. Arsenic.
A little bit every day. Mrs. Thornton said it would look like fever. Said no one would ever know. She paid me $50 and promised more if I kept quiet. And when they tried to hang me for his murder, Clara's voice shook with fury.
Did you keep quiet then, too? I wanted to speak up. I swear I did, but Vincent came to see me. He said if I told anyone he'd make sure I disappeared. He said there are places in the mountains where no one would ever find a body.