Then the shelf narrowed. She hadn't seen it from her earlier vantage point, a section twothirds of the way along where the rock wall came in sharply and the shelf reduced from 12 feet to about 5. At 5 feet, the cattle could still pass. But at 5 feet, with animals behind them pressing forward and the wall on their left and the drop to the creek bottom on their right, the leading animals stopped. When cattle at the front stop and cattle at the back keep coming, the middle compresses.
Compression in a narrow space with a drop edge on one side was exactly the scenario. Elias's four groupoup plan had been designed to avoid. Norah understood the problem the moment it developed. She was already moving, trying to slow the rear of the first group. But Pete and Garrett were still pushing from behind because they hadn't yet seen what was happening at the front.
The delay between the problem developing and the information reaching everyone who needed it was perhaps 90 seconds. 90 seconds was enough. The compression reached the leading animals just as the shelf narrowed and the cattle at the front. finding themselves pressed from behind to get into a wall with a drop on their right, made the collective decision that the drop was preferable to staying where they were. Three animals went off the shelf edge.
The drop to the creek bottom was 8 feet. Not fatal, but not inconsequential. Either cattle falling onto hard, rocky creek bed, landing badly the specific sounds of large animals in distress. The other cattle in the group spooked from the sound, adding to the compression, and for the next several minutes, the whole situation was controlled chaos. Elias arrived at a full gallop.
He assessed the scene in the specific way. He assessed emergencies, fast and complete. Before he reacted, and then he reacted with the efficiency of a man who had managed crises long enough to have sorted them into categories. He sent Caleb and two hands down into the creek bottom for the downed animals. He positioned himself at the shelf narrowing and used his horse to physically block the compression, giving the leading cattle time to work through the narrow section in small groups.
He called Garrett back from the rear push and had him hold the ungrouped cattle at the valley entrance until the shelf was clear. It took 40 minutes to fully manage. Of the three animals that went off the shelf, one was unhurt. One had a badly bruised leg that would require careful monitoring. One had broken its left fore leg in the fall and could not be moved.
Elias made the decision about the third animal without ceremony and without explanation. Caleb handled it. The sound carried up from the creek bottom, and then it was over, and nobody said anything about it. Norah sat on Juniper at the edge of the shelf and watched all of it happen. Elias came to her when it was finished.