“That smile says something.”
Tom shrugged.
“Then I guess I’ll bring a little gift to the trespassers’ party.”
Karen’s face changed.
“What does that mean?”
“Hope you ladies enjoy it.”
Then Tom turned and walked inside.
For the first time that morning, Karen did not look completely certain.
But she stayed.
That was her first mistake.
Tom did not poison the pool.
He did not tamper with the water.
He did not set a trap.
He did something far more useful.
He made coffee.
Then he sat at his kitchen table and opened the folder containing his closing documents.
Ten minutes later, Karen and her friends were still outside.
Tom found the survey.
Lot line.
Pool.
Deck.
Fence.
No shared-use note.
No easement.
Then the title report.
Nothing.
Then the HOA disclosure package.
Briarwood Hills Community Association maintained three amenities:
the clubhouse,
two tennis courts,
and a small community playground.
No pool.
Tom leaned back.
Outside, someone screamed happily before jumping into the water.
Tom opened his phone.
He called the HOA management company.
A woman named Melissa answered.
“Briarwood Hills management.”
“My name is Tom Harding. Seventeen Foxbridge Court.”
“Yes, Mr. Harding. How can I help?”
“I need to verify whether the HOA has any recorded access right to the swimming pool behind my house.”
Silence.
“Swimming pool?”
“Yes.”
“Your private pool?”
“That’s what I believe.”
“Why?”
“There are three board members’ friends swimming in it.”
Another pause.
“Can you hold?”
“Of course.”
Tom looked through the kitchen window.
Karen was back on the swan.
Two minutes later Melissa returned.
“Mr. Harding?”
“Yes.”
“I do not see any active HOA amenity designation on your parcel.”
“Any easement?”
“Not in our management file.”
“Temporary agreement?”
“I would need to check archived board records.”
“Please do.”
“I can send you what we have Monday.”
“Today would be better.”
“It’s Saturday.”
“I know.”
Tom looked toward the pool.
“So does Karen Peton.”
Silence.
Melissa lowered her voice.
“Karen is there?”
“In the pool.”
“Oh.”
That one syllable told Tom more than anything else.
“You sound unsurprised.”
“I didn’t say that.”
“You didn’t have to.”
Melissa sighed.
“Mr. Harding, I’m going to contact our property manager.”
“Good.”
Tom hung up.
Then called a locksmith.
By eleven-thirty, Karen and her friends finally left.
She passed the patio door on her way toward the gate.
Tom stood inside.
Karen lifted the brass key.
“See you next weekend.”
Tom smiled.
“Maybe.”
She paused.
“What’s that supposed to mean?”
“Exactly what it sounds like.”
Karen walked out.
Tom waited until the gate closed.
Then photographed the lock.
By noon, a locksmith had replaced the cylinder.
Tom asked him to keep the old hardware.
“Problem?”
the locksmith asked.
“Maybe.”
“Someone copied a key?”
“Apparently.”
The locksmith inspected the old lock.
“This is an older cylinder.”
“Could the previous owner have handed out keys?”
“Sure.”
“How many?”
The locksmith shrugged.
“As many as he wanted.”
Tom looked toward Karen’s house two doors down.
That evening, he installed a temporary security camera over the gate.
The following morning, another camera went over the pool deck.
Monday afternoon, the HOA property manager called.
Her name was Sandra Wells.
“Mr. Harding, I found something.”
Tom sat straighter.
“What?”
“There was a temporary pool-use agreement.”
Karen had not completely lied.
Seven years earlier, Briarwood Hills’ community pool had been closed during a major renovation.
Tom’s home then belonged to a retired surgeon named Harold Beckett.
Harold agreed to let the HOA use his private pool for six scheduled events.
Three senior water-aerobics sessions.
Two adult socials.
One children’s swimming afternoon.
The agreement was extremely specific.
Access was allowed only on designated dates.
An HOA representative would supervise.
The association provided temporary liability coverage.
The license ended automatically on August 31 of that year.
No renewal.
No continuing right.
No easement.
No community status.
Tom read the scanned document twice.
At the bottom was a signature.
Amenities Committee Coordinator: Karen Peton.
Tom stared.
That explained the key.
Karen had been one of the people authorized to access the gate seven years earlier.
The agreement required all temporary keys to be returned after expiration.
Apparently Karen had decided that section did not apply to her.
Tom called Sandra.
“Does Karen know this agreement expired?”
“She signed it.”
“That isn’t what I asked.”
Sandra hesitated.
“I would assume she knows.”
“Has the HOA continued treating my pool as an amenity?”
“No.”
“Any insurance?”
“No.”
“Maintenance payments?”
“No.”
“Scheduled use?”
“No.”
“Then she’s just entering.”
Sandra exhaled.
“Yes.”
Tom printed the agreement.
Then drafted a letter.
He kept it simple.
Karen Peton: