He asked two questions that were precise and indicated he understood exactly what kind of evidence mattered and what kind didn't. Then he said, "I'll need to see the animals." "We ride at midnight," Rachel said. "They rode at midnight." The three of them, and Rachel led them to the ridge above Hollister's lower pens, and Henderson crouched in the dark, and looked at the animals below with the eyes of a man who had looked at 40 years of cattle under every condition of weather and light.
And after a long moment, he said very quietly, "I can see four from here that I'd want to look at more closely, but I can also see the general shape of what's been done." Rachel said, "Will you testify to what you've seen?" Henderson looked at her. "In front of whoever needs to hear it," she said. "The cattle association, the territorial office, whoever has jurisdiction and will actually act on it."
Henderson was quiet for a moment. Yes, he said, "I will." They rode back to Witcom Ranch in the dark and arrived before first light, and Henderson slept in the bunk house, and Jesse made coffee at the first gray edge of morning. And Rachel sat at the kitchen table with her ledger open, and wrote everything down, every date, and every word, and every witness, because documentation was the only weapon she fully trusted. Jesse appeared in the kitchen doorway with a cup and set it on the table beside her without being asked.
She looked at it, looked up at him. Henderson will help, Jesse said. I know. She looked back at this ledger. It might not be enough.
Hollister has resources we don't. He also has a foreman, Jesse said, who has been working for him for 8 years and knows where every fence is and every pen is and what happened in every one of them. He paused. Men like Thomas Reed eventually have to decide which side of a line they're standing on. And when the evidence starts stacking up, that decision gets easier.
Rachel looked at him. How do you know about Reed? She said. Jesse sat down across from her. Because I asked about him in town before I rode to find Henderson.
Reed's been Hollister's foreman since he was 34 years old. He's done everything Hollister asked him to do. But there are two things a man like Reed draws a line at. He held her gaze. Violence against a woman who's done nothing wrong and losing everything he's worked for because the man he worked for pushed too far.
You think he's close to that line? I think we're about to give him a reason to cross it, Jesse said. Rachel sat with that for a moment. Outside the ranch was waking up. The cattle were beginning to move.