The following spring, when Isaiah turned thirteen, Denise asked what he wanted for his birthday. He did not ask for a phone or an expensive game. He asked to visit the apartment building where he and his mother had lived. Denise hesitated because she knew the visit might bring back difficult memories, but she also understood that he was old enough to decide what parts of his past he wanted to face. She spoke with his counselor and then helped arrange a day trip to Atlanta. Janice offered to meet them there, and Marcus said he could join if Isaiah wanted him present. Isaiah said he did.
The building looked smaller than he remembered. Its brick walls were faded, and a row of trash cans stood beside the entrance where his mother had once planted flowers in old coffee tins. The manager had changed, and the apartment had been rented to another family. Denise had contacted the current tenant in advance, asking only whether they might see the old hallway and the outside of the door. The woman had agreed to a brief visit. Isaiah stood on the landing where he used to wait for his mother to come home. He could still remember the sound of her keys and the way she called his name before she reached the door.
The pencil marks on the doorframe were gone. A fresh coat of paint covered the place where his mother had measured his height. Isaiah touched the smooth wood and felt an unexpected wave of anger. He had imagined the marks waiting for him, evidence that his childhood had existed exactly as he remembered it. The new tenant apologized, though she had done nothing wrong. Denise told Isaiah that the marks had been part of the old apartment, but they were not the only record of his life with Renee. She had photographs, recipes, stories, and the boy standing beside her who remembered. Isaiah nodded but did not speak for a long time.
They walked afterward to a small park where Renee had sometimes taken him on Sunday afternoons. The playground had been rebuilt, but the oak trees were familiar. Isaiah sat beneath one of them while Janice unpacked sandwiches from a cooler. Marcus joined them with bottles of water. Nobody tried to turn the trip into a cheerful outing. They let Isaiah look around and decide when he was ready to talk. After a while he asked whether they could take a photograph of him beside the tree. Denise stood behind the camera. Isaiah held the notebook of family contacts in one hand and smiled only when he wanted to.
At lunch he told them that he had been afraid the apartment would prove he had imagined the good parts of his childhood. Seeing the hallway had made him sad, but it had also reminded him of things he had forgotten: the way his mother decorated the door at Christmas,