Rich Woman Spat in a 13-Year-Old Girl's Face in First Class — Then 3 Passengers Started Recording

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"What were you thinking when the defendant spat at you?" Hannah asked.

Nia looked toward Camille and then back at the prosecutor. "I thought I must have done something wrong without knowing what," she said. "Not because I believed her. Because when a grown-up keeps telling you that you don't belong, part of you starts trying to figure out what will make them stop."

The room was very quiet. Nia continued before the prosecutor asked another question. "I knew I had a ticket. I knew I hadn't stolen it. I knew I wasn't hurting anybody. But she talked like none of that mattered."

Douglas asked his questions respectfully but firmly. He tested Nia's memory about the position of Meredith's glass, the timing of crew involvement, and whether the videos captured everything she recalled. Nia sometimes answered, "I don't know," and once corrected a detail she had said earlier about the order of two comments. Douglas asked whether the attention her mother received had affected the way Nia understood what happened. She considered the question carefully. "People treated it like a bigger story afterward," she said. "But it was already big to me when I was sitting there alone."

The answer was not rehearsed. Camille knew because she had never heard her daughter say it that way before. She pressed a tissue against her eyes and kept her face still. Whatever verdict the jury eventually reached, Nia had done the difficult thing of telling the truth without making it larger than she remembered. After leaving the witness stand, Nia sat with the support specialist and asked to go somewhere quiet. Camille followed when court recessed. They walked to a small room, closed the door, and sat together without speaking for several minutes.

Meredith testified later. She described the flight as a stressful day and said she had been drinking. She claimed that the contact had not been deliberate. Hannah asked why she had questioned Nia's entitlement to the seat and why she had continued after the airline verified the boarding pass. Meredith gave long explanations about changing standards and the airline's treatment of premium passengers. Under further questioning, she acknowledged that she had no evidence Nia had taken anyone else's seat. The jury watched her struggle to explain why a child's sweatshirt had seemed to justify an accusation of theft.

Hannah played the most complete recording again. Meredith watched herself lean toward Nia and spit. When asked how the motion was consistent with an accidental sneeze, she said the video did not show what she felt inside her body. Hannah did not raise her voice. She asked a final question about whether Meredith had apologized to Nia immediately afterward. Meredith answered that she had said it was an accident. The prosecutor let the jury decide whether that was an apology.

News in the same category

Rich Woman Spat in a 13-Year-Old Girl's Face in First Class — Then 3 Passengers Started Recording

30 Part