Talia carried the violin because she never willingly left it behind. Its black case had a broken latch and a handle that rubbed against her palm. A little brass plate near the hinge was worn almost smooth, but the name Isaiah Brooks could still be read when sunlight struck it. Isaiah had been Denise's father, a patient, gentle man who repaired instruments in a little workshop in the Ironbound neighborhood. He had died the previous winter, leaving behind three boxes of tools, a notebook filled with musical exercises, and the violin he had taught Talia to play.
When Talia was four, Isaiah had noticed her tapping rhythms with spoons while he worked. At five she could sing back complicated melodies after hearing them once. At six she learned to hear when a string was the smallest fraction out of tune. By seven, she was playing pieces that made the retired music teacher down the street sit quietly and wipe her eyes. Her grandfather never called her a genius. He said she was a child with excellent ears and a stubborn heart, and that both gifts would be wasted if she forgot to practice slowly.
He also taught her something more difficult than music. He taught her that audiences could be wrong, that applause was not the same as worth, and that the person holding the instrument mattered more than the price of the wood. Once, after a customer laughed at the old violin on his bench, Isaiah had turned the instrument over and pointed to a tiny carved crescent moon near the base of its neck. He told Talia that the mark belonged to a maker who had created beautiful instruments without ever becoming famous. 'Listen first,' he said. 'Decide what something is worth afterward.'
Denise had never been a musician. As a girl, she had watched her father repair violins while she did homework at the kitchen table, but she had chosen a career in healthcare and never regretted it. After Talia was born, however, she began to understand why her father had devoted his life to sound. When her daughter played, the apartment seemed larger. It could hold memory, anger, fear, and joy at the same time. In recent months, Talia had practiced with a folded towel under the strings when their downstairs neighbor complained, imagining the notes even when the instrument made only a whisper.
The rain began near the end of their job search. It came down in heavy slanting sheets, turning the sidewalks silver and driving crowds beneath store awnings. Denise found a narrow shelter beside a flower shop, then checked the bus schedule on her cracked phone. The next bus they could afford would take them toward Penn Station, where they would change trains for home. Her battery read seven percent. Talia watched water slip through the seam of her left shoe and tried not to shiver.