At a pretrial conference, Benjamin Hale acknowledged to Caroline that the driving footage did not show the dramatic fishtail described by Rourke. He did not agree that the maneuver was necessarily safe. Andrew heard the statement later and felt an unreasonable surge of hope. If the prosecutor accepted that a central part of the officer's description was unsupported, surely the charge could end. Instead the office continued to evaluate the case, and a replacement attorney, Laura Benton, became responsible for trial preparation. Andrew found himself having to explain his video and chronology again to someone who had not been present for the earlier conversations.
Laura Benton was diligent, direct, and burdened by a calendar full of cases. She studied the body-camera recording, the reports, and the citations. She believed Rourke had observed a fast, improper maneuver and that a jury could weigh whether it amounted to recklessness. She also saw the Tesla recording and understood that portions of the officer's account might be challenged. The evidence did not relieve her of decisions; it complicated them. In her private notes, she listed the differences between what the officer described and what the camera actually showed. She did not know yet how those differences would sound after a defense lawyer questioned him under oath.
Andrew occasionally imagined that prosecutors kept the case alive to punish him for refusing to plead. Caroline discouraged him from assuming a motive he could not establish. "We can prove that they had the video," she said. "We can prove what it depicts and when they received it. We cannot prove what each person thought without evidence. Don't weaken a strong factual case by putting a guess where a fact belongs." Andrew knew she was right, even though the uncertainty left him without the simple explanation he craved. If the process could continue through error, disagreement, and ordinary inertia, that was perhaps more troubling than imagining one bad man coordinating it all.
The following spring, the inactive signal finally began operating. Patricia sent Andrew a photograph of the first green light above the intersection. He studied it for a long time. Drivers now took their turns in orderly phases, although some still ignored the markings and others hurried through yellow lights. The city had fixed a dangerous ambiguity on the road. His own case remained unresolved. He drove through the intersection one Saturday with Emily beside him, waited for the arrow, and made the turn at a perfectly ordinary speed. His hands still shook at the sight of a police cruiser parked beyond the crossing.
By the first anniversary of the garage encounter, Andrew had learned that an unresolved court case could coexist with ordinary happiness. Lucy turned eight and asked for a bicycle with gears. Ben learned to swim and surprised everybody by jumping into the deep end after weeks of clinging to the ladder.