Police Chief Slapped a Woman Sitting on a Park Bench — Next Morning, He Learned She Was a Judge

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

This is Maya Rodriguez from the Asheville Citizen Times. I'm calling about the incident at Riverside Park this afternoon. Do you have a moment? Brenda hesitates. She knows Maya by reputation.

Sharp reporter. Doesn't pull punches. Has been covering police accountability issues for 2 years. Not tonight, Brenda says, but call me tomorrow morning. Of course.

I just want to make sure you're all right and to let you know that if you decide to share your side of the story, we'll run it. Thank you. I'll think about it. She hangs up and turns to Amara. Pack a bag.

We're staying at Aunt Patricia's tonight. Why? Because by tomorrow morning this is going to get much bigger and I need one more night before that happens. They pack quickly. Clothes, toiletries, and Amara's schoolwork.

Brenda grabs the folder from the park, the one about Jamal Reed, and tucks it into her overnight bag. She doesn't know why. Maybe because it feels important to keep that work close to remember why she's doing any of this in the first place. They leave through the back door, avoiding the news van out front. Brenda drives carefully, checking her mirrors more than usual.

Her hands are steady on the wheel now, but her mind is racing with everything that comes next. By the time she pulls into Patricia Hayes's driveway 20 minutes later, the video has been viewed over half a million times. And somewhere across town, Chief Gerald Hutchinson is sitting in his living room staring at his phone and starting to realize that this isn't going away. The earthquake hit at 6:30 Friday morning. Maya Rodriguez's by line appears on the Asheville Citizen Times homepage.

Woman assaulted by police chief is Superior Court Judge Brenda Lawrence. The article is concise, professional, devastating. It identifies Brenda by name and title. Presiding Judge of the Superior Court, Criminal Division, District 28, 15 years on the bench. More than 200 felony trials involving the Asheville Police Department.

Cases where Chief Hutchinson himself testified. Maya includes a quote from a retired attorney. Judge Lawrence has signed every search warrant, every arrest warrant, every detention order through her courtroom for a decade. If Hutchinson made an arrest in Asheville, her signature is in that file. The article doesn't editorialize.

The facts speak for themselves. By 7:00 a. m., Associated Press picks it up. By 8, it's trending nationally. By 9, cable news runs segments with legal analysts. Chief Hutchinson reads the article at 6:43 a. m., still in his bathrobe, coffee frozen halfway to his lips.

He reads it twice, then a third time. Judge Lawrence, the woman at the park, the woman whose video now has 2 million views. She's a superior court judge. His hands shake. He calls Alan Foster, the city manager.

Four rings before Foster answers, voice tight. Tell me you didn't know, Foster says. I didn't know. You slapped a judge, Gerald. A sitting judge.

I didn't know who she was. That's not the point. Fosters's voice rises, then drops. The point is, you assaulted someone in public and now the entire country is watching. It was a misunderstanding.

News in the same category

Police Chief Slapped a Woman Sitting on a Park Bench — Next Morning, He Learned She Was a Judge

15 Part