OFFICERS HUMILIATED A WOMAN OUTSIDE COURT — THEN A COURT CLERK CAME RUNNING THROUGH THE DOORS

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Asked questions.

Ruled.

Nothing in her voice suggested that less than forty minutes earlier, a courthouse officer had ordered her away from the building where she presided.

At 11:43, the morning docket ended.

Thomas closed the courtroom doors.

Kesha removed her glasses.

Only then did her shoulders drop slightly.

Thomas approached.

“You okay?”

“Yes.”

“That answer is getting less convincing.”

Kesha looked toward him.

“I’m angry.”

“Good.”

She almost smiled.

“Why is that good?”

“Because I thought you were going to tell me you were fine.”

Kesha looked at the stack of recovered files.

One packet had a torn corner.

Her notes were out of order.

Nothing irreparable.

Still.

Thomas sat in the chair across from her.

“Do you want to know what’s happening downstairs?”

“Not yet.”

“Kesha.”

She looked at him.

Thomas rarely used her first name in chambers unless something mattered.

“The video is everywhere.”

Kesha closed her eyes.

Of course it was.

“How much?”

“All of it, basically.”

“Wonderful.”

“Not the word I’d use.”

She leaned back.

Then asked:

“Did anyone photograph the sealed pages?”

“We’re checking.”

That concerned her more than the humiliation.

Thomas noticed.

“You really don’t care about the rest?”

“I care.”

She looked toward the window.

“I just don’t want my embarrassment to become more important than someone else’s privacy.”

That answer was exactly why Thomas respected her.

Kesha Williams had spent eleven years as a judge.

Before that, she was a public defender.

Then a federal prosecutor.

Then a civil-litigation partner.

People often assumed judges enjoyed power.

Kesha distrusted anyone who enjoyed it too much.

Her father, Leonard Williams, had been a Memphis bus mechanic.

He used to say:

“Authority is a tool. If you need people scared of you to prove you have it, you probably don't know how to use it.”

Kesha thought about him often from the bench.

She had been appointed to fill a judicial vacancy at thirty-eight, then won election the following year.

Her courtroom developed a reputation for being strict but predictable.

Attorneys knew what she expected.

Be prepared.

Do not lie.

Do not waste time.

Do not humiliate people simply because you can.

A young prosecutor once referred to a defendant as “this kind of person.”

Kesha stopped him.

“What kind?”

He had no answer.

She never forgot the silence.

That same kind of silence had appeared on the courthouse steps when Mercer demanded that she leave.

He had decided something about her before gathering information.

The fact that she happened to be a judge made the story dramatic.

To Kesha, it made the underlying problem harder to ignore.

Because she knew exactly what people would say.

He picked the wrong woman.

She hated that phrase.

It implied there was a right one.

Lieutenant Carla Jennings reviewed Mercer’s body-camera video before lunch.

She expected ambiguity.

There was none.

The recording began before Kesha reached the entrance.

Mercer was speaking with another officer.

He saw Kesha approaching.

The other officer said:

“Staff entrance is open.”

Mercer answered:

“She doesn’t look staff.”

Jennings paused the recording.

Replayed it.

Then continued.

Kesha arrived.

Polite.

Calm.

Credential in briefcase.

Mercer refusing to let her retrieve it.

Kesha explaining.

Mercer escalating.

Then another remark the crowd had not heard clearly.

When Kesha said she had court at nine, Mercer muttered:

“Everybody wants to play lawyer once they get near these steps.”

Jennings leaned back.

Kesha had never claimed to be a lawyer.

Then came the briefcase.

The files.

The order not to touch them.

And the laugh.

Maybe now you’ll learn to follow instructions.

Jennings closed her eyes.

The problem was no longer a mistaken identity.

Mistakes happened.

The problem was what Mercer did after uncertainty became an excuse for contempt.

She immediately notified courthouse administration.

Mercer was reassigned away from public-facing duties pending review.

Not fired.

Not arrested.

Administrative leave did not equal guilt.

Kesha insisted that distinction be respected.

When Chief Court Security Officer Martin Price called her that afternoon, he began:

“Judge Williams, I want to personally apologize—”

Kesha interrupted.

“You didn’t stop me.”

“No.”

“Then don’t apologize for him.”

Price paused.

“We failed institutionally.”

“That’s a better conversation.”

He sighed.

“I was hoping you’d make this easy.”

“You know me better than that.”

“Yes.”

He almost laughed.

Then became serious.

“We’re opening a formal investigation.”

“Good.”

“You’ll need to give a statement.”

“I will.”

“Do you want Mercer removed?”

Kesha stared at the wall.

“I want you to investigate him.”

“That isn’t what I asked.”

“I know.”

She continued.

“If I tell you the outcome I want before you collect facts, how am I different from what happened downstairs?”

Price said nothing.

Kesha softened slightly.

“But preserve everything.”

“Already done.”

“Access logs too.”

“Why?”

“I want to know whether my credential had been temporarily deactivated or whether he simply chose not to check.”

Price paused.

“Good question.”

Kesha looked toward the clock.

“I get paid to ask them.”

By midafternoon, the video had crossed local news.

Then regional news.

Then national social media.

The most popular clip lasted twenty-three seconds.

Mercer blocking Kesha.

News in the same category

OFFICERS HUMILIATED A WOMAN OUTSIDE COURT — THEN A COURT CLERK CAME RUNNING THROUGH THE DOORS

5 Part