Denise closed her eyes. She remembered a highway stop when Simone was nine and Jordan was six, an officer shining a light into their minivan and asking whether Malcolm owned it. She remembered their children silent in the rear seats and Malcolm afterward insisting that everything had been fine. They had discussed how to handle police encounters before their son began driving, and both had hated that the conversation was necessary. Now their youngest was hundreds of miles away at college, and the lesson had come home again. Denise wanted Malcolm to sit down and eat. Malcolm wanted to make sure the footage did not disappear. They agreed to do both, in that order.
The camera application required two-factor authentication and recorded each login. Malcolm had argued for those features during procurement because the footage belonged to the association, not to whichever director happened to want it. Now, with his name at the top of the board's officers list, he faced a problem he had never anticipated. He needed the footage for himself. If he simply downloaded it under his own authority, an opposing attorney might reasonably question his access to evidence he was responsible for safeguarding. Denise listened as he explained the dilemma, then asked him a question she often put to anxious parents at school. What would he advise someone else to do?
"Ask the administrator to preserve it," he answered.
"Then do that."
He called the system's contracted administrator, requested preservation of all cameras covering Magnolia Lane and the southern gate between seven and eight that evening, and asked for an unaltered export with metadata and access logs. He copied the association's vice president and counsel on the request, noting that he was recusing himself from decisions about release of footage related to his complaint. He also saved his own account of the encounter while details remained fresh. He had to stop twice because his hands began trembling again. Denise sat across the island, writing down what he remembered about the officer's words. Neither tried to improve the story. They wanted the sequence as it had actually occurred.
The administrator called back just after nine. Several feeds were available. Video from the streetlight covered Malcolm's driveway and the patrol car's position clearly. Sound from the camera facing the public approach was less complete than the sales presentation had promised; a passing delivery truck masked the first few exchanges. The body camera worn by Kessler would likely be necessary to establish every word. Malcolm felt an odd sense of relief that the equipment was not perfect. A flawless machine that solved everything would have been comforting, but life rarely offered anything so generous. He wanted a record that could be tested, not a legend his neighbors would repeat.