In four cases she disagreed. In two of those she concluded, after watching him work the horse a second time, that his read was more accurate than hers. In the other two she remained confident in her contrary view. Caleb was watching her watch Reyes. You're going to dispute too, he said quietly, coming to stand beside her.
I am. Which ones? She named them. The gray gelding whose shoulder had been the concern on day one and had fully resolved and a bay mare from Dunmore's ranch who had a scar on her left cannon bone that Reyes had flagged without fully assessing the range of motion below it. The gray gelding I'll concede if he works him at a trot, she said.
If Reyes sees what I see, he'll pass him. If he doesn't, then Reyes is right and I'm wrong. And the mare? The scar is old. The joint below it has full range of motion.
Reyes assessed the scar without testing the function. That's an incomplete assessment. Caleb looked at the mare. You're going to tell him that. Yes.
He won't appreciate it. He'll appreciate accuracy more than he minds the correction, she said. He's a professional. His reputation depends on correct assessments, not comfortable ones. When Reyes had completed his initial pass, he gave his preliminary findings to Fulton.
57 accepted. Five flagged for secondary review. The five included the gray gelding, the scarred bay mare, the two additional horses above contract, and a young roan from Lester's ranch that Eleanor had not anticipated. Fulton asked if the drive's representatives wanted to respond to the flagged animals before the final determination. Caleb looked at Eleanor.
Go a head. She walked to the examination area. She addressed the gray gelding first. She asked Reyes to work him at a trot across the examination ground. Reyes looked at her with the neutral expression of a professional deciding whether this was interference or legitimate input, then nodded once and took the horse through his paces.
The gelding moved clean, shoulder fully resolved, gait even, no compensation. Reyes reassessed without being asked. He wrote something in the ledger. The scarred bay mare was next. Eleanor pointed out scar, stated its approximate age based on the tissue quality, and demonstrated the full range of motion in the joint below it by working the leg herself, explaining what she was doing and why each movement was relevant to the working standard.
Reyes watched. He took the leg himself and repeated the assessment. He looked at Eleanor. Where did you learn to evaluate scar tissue on a joint? My mother, she said.
She spent 30 years assessing horses for breeding and sale. She believed that a visual inspection without a function test was an incomplete inspection. She was right, he said. He wrote in the ledger. The two additional horses above contract passed without further discussion.
They were in excellent condition and there was no legitimate basis for rejection. The young roan from Lester's ranch was harder. Eleanor examined him carefully and found what Reyes had found, a subtle irregularity in his right hind movement that was consistent with a developing splint, an inflammation of the small bones on the inside of the leg. It was early, possibly temporary, possibly progressive. She could not in good conscience argue against the flag.