Franklin looked from daughter to father.
“I preferred her when she was seven.”
“So did I,” Jack said.
Word spread.
But not the way Hannah expected.
People did not suddenly rush out and buy ducks.
Most growers were too practical for that.
They came to watch.
A vineyard manager from five miles north visited.
Then two smaller growers.
Then Dr. Celia Hart from the county extension office heard about the trial and called Hannah.
“I understand you’re using ducks in Pinot Noir.”
“Carefully.”
“Good answer.”
Celia visited the following week.
She walked the vineyard.
Reviewed Hannah’s sampling sheets.
Asked about stocking density, duration, soil moisture, shoot damage, supplemental feed, fencing labor, predation risk, and sanitation.
Jack watched from a distance.
He had heard experts praise interesting ideas before.
He expected Celia to become excited.
Instead she became irritatingly careful.
“This isn’t proof of a broadly transferable practice,” she said.
Hannah nodded.
“I know.”
“Your flock is trained.”
“Yes.”
“You’re actively herding them.”
“Yes.”
“You’re moving them according to soil conditions.”
“Yes.”
“So another grower cannot buy eighty ducks, release them, and expect this result.”
“No.”
Jack liked her immediately.
Celia looked toward the flock.
“But you do have something worth documenting.”
Hannah tried not to smile.
“What?”
“A functioning on-farm integrated pest-management trial.”
Not a revolution.
Not a miracle.
A trial.
That mattered more to Hannah.
The first serious setback came three weeks later.
One morning, she found twelve vines in Block Three with obvious leaf damage.
Not snails.
Ducks.
The flock had slipped through a loose section of temporary fence late the previous afternoon and spent almost forty minutes where they did not belong.
Jack found Hannah kneeling beside a damaged plant.
She looked sick.
“I missed the clip.”
Jack examined the vine.
“It’ll live.”
“That isn’t the point.”
“No.”
“I told everyone this was controlled.”
“It was. Then a fence failed.”
“I installed the fence.”
Jack sat on an overturned bucket.
For years he had been the one warning her not to trust experiments.
Now their positions reversed.
“You know what farming is?”
Hannah glared.
“Please don’t become philosophical.”
“It’s mostly finding out what failed after you were sure you checked it.”
“That’s comforting.”
“You damaged twelve vines.”
“I know.”
“Out of how many?”
“That doesn’t excuse it.”
“No.”
Jack looked at her.
“But if you only count evidence when it supports your idea, you’re not doing science. You’re advertising.”
Hannah stopped.
Her father pointed toward her notebook.
“Write it down.”
She did.
Fence failure.
Unauthorized flock access.
Leaf damage.
Corrective action.
After that, every temporary gate received two clips.
The incident spread too.
Franklin heard by evening.
Hannah expected jokes.
Instead he said, “How bad?”
“Twelve vines.”
“Learn anything?”
“Yes.”
“Then it cost less than most lessons.”
The duck joke was changing.
Not disappearing.
Changing.
By late summer, the flock had become part of Miller Vineyard’s routine.
Not every day.
Not every block.
Never once fruit began ripening low enough to interest them.
They were most useful during wet pest windows and around selected cover-crop areas.
Hannah tracked labor.
Feed.
Fencing.
Damage.
Pest pressure.
The economics were less spectacular than social media would later make them sound.
The ducks did not eliminate pesticides.
They did not make the vineyard self-sufficient.
They did not work equally well everywhere.
They required labor.
They required management.
They needed shelter, water, health care, predator protection, and someone willing to move temporary fence in rain.
But they changed one important thing.
Jack no longer viewed every pest problem as a question with only one category of answer.
That autumn, he and Hannah sat at the kitchen table reviewing season records.
Jack adjusted his glasses.
“Feed cost more than you projected.”
“Fourteen percent.”
“Fencing too.”
“Because we doubled clips.”
He looked at her.
“Very funny.”
“Duck damage?”
“Acceptable overall. Not acceptable in Block Three.”
“Labor?”
“Higher at first. Lower once they were trained.”
“Chemical savings?”
“Meaningful during snail pressure. Not enough to pay for everything in year one.”
Jack nodded.
“So I was right.”
Hannah looked at him.
“About?”
“Expensive lawn ornaments.”
“You want me to sell them?”
Jack immediately frowned.
“No.”
She smiled.
“Thought so.”
He closed the notebook.
“You keeping all eighty?”
“Probably sixty-five over winter.”
“What happens to the others?”
“I have three growers interested.”
“Franklin?”