In town, the men at the Painted Star saloon greeted Nathaniel like a visiting king. Land broker Horace Pike wore a silver watch chain and a smile that never reached his eyes. Sheriff Vernon Rusk had a square red face and fingers stained by tobacco. Both men congratulated Nathaniel on his purchase and suggested that Eliza Ward could be removed within a day. Nathaniel ordered coffee and listened without drinking it.
“She’s not right in the head,” Pike said. “Her husband drowned, and she started talking about missing records and buried strangers. Last month she threatened a survey crew with a shotgun.” Rusk leaned back. “I can clear her out, legal and quiet. No need to trouble yourself.” Nathaniel watched a scarred gunman at the far end of the bar stop playing cards when Eliza's name was spoken. “I promised her ten days,” he answered. “I keep my promises.”
Pike’s smile thinned. “That property has been a nuisance for years.” Nathaniel looked directly at him. “Funny. I paid enough for it that you ought to be pleased.” The broker laughed too loudly, while the sheriff reached for his whiskey. Nathaniel left before sunset and noticed the scarred gunman following him at a distance.
He took a room above the livery rather than sleep in the empty ranch house. In the darkness, he opened Daniel’s last letter for perhaps the thousandth time. The paper had worn thin at its folds. Daniel had written about a route that existed on no public map and about men who intended to make a fortune by controlling the water along it. At the bottom, squeezed into the margin, was a sentence Nathaniel had never understood: Ask about the woman who keeps the blue ribbon.
The next morning, Nathaniel returned to Eliza’s cabin carrying flour, coffee, lamp oil, and a sack of oats. She met him at the gate with her shotgun. “I didn’t ask for charity.” He set the supplies down. “They’re not charity. Consider them payment for answering one question.” She looked at him with open suspicion. “I don't owe you answers.” He took Daniel’s letter from his pocket and showed her the final line.
Eliza read it once, then again. Her fingers rose to the collar of her dress, where a narrow blue ribbon had been tied around a small brass key. She stepped backward. “Where did you get that?” Nathaniel felt the air leave his lungs. “My brother wrote it. His name was Daniel Vale.” She looked toward the cottonwood. “You have his eyes,” she whispered.
For a moment Nathaniel could hear only the mare stamping in the corral. “Where is he?” Eliza pressed her lips together. “Come inside,” she said. “And bring the coffee.” She made him wait while she bolted the door and covered the window facing the road. Only then did she tell him that Daniel had died on her land, and that the man buried beside her husband was not a stranger after all.