The ambush changed everything. Once Deputy Price returned with the wagon, Vance had a direct attack on civilians, a wounded suspect, and physical evidence linking the highwaymen to the threatening note and the stolen payroll route. The sheriff notified the territorial marshal again, this time with a request for immediate support based on an attempted armed robbery. He also ordered the freight company to send a representative to his office and made it clear that the county would not assume responsibility for protecting a payroll shipment whose owner refused every reasonable precaution. By evening the company had agreed to postpone the wagon for forty-eight hours.
Vance brought Gideon into his office that night and closed the door. He spread six names across the desk: men who had worked for the freight company, used the telegraph, or served as temporary deputies in recent months. One of them was Owen Fitch, a stable owner who had recently purchased three horses despite carrying overdue debts. Another was a clerk named Victor Hale, no relation to Gideon, who had passed information about payroll dates to a man he claimed was a prospective contractor. Vance disliked making accusations on suspicion alone, but he was willing to question everyone on the list. Gideon said the strongest protection for their case was to avoid deciding who was guilty before they had evidence.
The next day Gideon and Clara visited the telegraph office while Vance's deputies interviewed the stable hands. Clara noticed a stack of discarded message slips on a shelf near the operator's desk. Among them was a copy of the freight company's original schedule sent from the mine office to a shipping broker, bearing an annotation in a different hand: NORTH ROAD, TWO GUARDS. The operator said the note was ordinary, meant for the wagon escort, but Clara remembered that the ambushers had been positioned exactly where a messenger carrying such information would pass. She asked who had collected duplicate schedules during the previous week. The operator named Fitch.
At the stable, Deputy Price found a horse bearing a fresh saddle sore matching the shape of the gear used by one of the ambushers, along with a dark leather rifle wrap in a tack room. Fitch claimed the items belonged to customers. Vance questioned him formally and, with the necessary warrant, searched his office, where a ledger recorded payments for "night oats" from a man using the initials S.R. The amounts were too large for ordinary feed, and the entries corresponded with reported movements along the canyon road. Fitch still denied knowing Rourke, but his confidence had begun to fail.
The case was not solved by the ledger. Gideon had seen too many clever men escape because someone rushed to declare victory over scraps of paper. He asked whether Fitch would identify the supplier behind the payments if Vance offered to tell the prosecutor about his cooperation. Fitch's face turned gray. He admitted that a red-scarf rider named Bennett had bought hay and received messages for the gang, but he insisted he never knew they would attack the payroll wagon. Vance recorded the statement and warned him that helping armed robbers was not a small matter merely because the stable itself had remained clean.
Clara looked down at her hands. "And if somebody gets hurt because I spoke?"