Miss Hartwell, he said, thank you for coming. She went up the steps and stood across the porch from him, close enough to talk far enough that she wasn't committing to anything. You have 20 minutes. Vale nodded. He didn't sit back down.
He put his hands in his coat pockets and looked out at the road the way a man looks at something he built and is watching. Come apart. I'm not going to threaten you, he said. I think we're past that. Creed was threatening me 3 days ago.
Creed acts on his judgment when I'm not present. I'm not always happy with his judgment. He looked at her then. I want to talk to you the way I should have talked to your father years ago before things went as far as they did. Clara said nothing.
She gave him the silence and let him fill it. I borrowed heavily to build the new elevator. Vale said more heavily than was prudent. As it turns out, the railroad arrangement I have requires me to deliver a contracted volume of grain every season. If I fall short, the railroad can cancel the siding access, and my creditors can call everything at once."
He paused. " What I've built is the only efficient grain shipping operation in this county. The railroad connection, the elevator capacity, the freight routes. If it collapses, it doesn't just hurt me. The men I employ lose their wages.
Farmers who've already stored grain in my elevator get tied up in bankruptcy proceedings for years. The whole county's shipping infrastructure falls apart. That's an argument for a solvent business. Clara said, not for defrauding farmers. I know what I've done.
He said it without flinching. And that surprised her. I'm not standing here telling you I was right. I'm telling you I believed. And still believe that some farmers taking a loss was the cost of keeping a working system alive.
A system that benefits everyone in the long run. Some farmers, Clara said. You chose which ones? Yes, the ones who couldn't fight back. Vale was quiet a moment.
The ones who were least positioned to verify the numbers independently. That's the same thing. He didn't argue it. She had come here ready for threats, for legal maneuvers, for another version of what Creed had done in the Hartwell yard three days ago. She had not been ready for this, for a man stating plainly what he had done, and asking her to weigh it against something.
It was harder to answer. Righteous anger was easy to maintain when the person you were angry at was performing villain. Vale wasn't performing anything. He was just tired. Your father understood something, Vale said.