Renee called her the woman with the invisible clipboard. My sister was younger than me by six years, a middle-school librarian with an unshakable gift for noticing when children felt excluded. When she brought Isaac and Hannah over, she often sat on my front steps, taking off her shoes while the children raced around the yard. She saw Vivian watching one afternoon and asked why I didn't tell the woman to mind her own business. I said I had spent my working life inside other people's homes. I knew how much easier it was to repair a cracked switch than an ugly quarrel between neighbors. Renee said silence wasn't always the same thing as peace. I told her I hadn't bought the house to fight over it, and she let the subject rest.
That fall my company was busier than it had been in months. A school district had contracted us to replace damaged exterior lighting on two campuses, and I was training a young apprentice named Marcus Bell, who had never held a job with regular hours before. Marcus was nineteen, clever with his hands, and easily discouraged when a complicated job took longer than expected. I liked teaching him because I remembered the electrician who had looked past my first mistakes and shown me how to check a circuit twice before trusting it. Business was steady, but the profits were modest. The mortgage, insurance, wages, and supplies always claimed their portions before I got to pay myself.
Halloween mattered to me because it was one evening when nobody asked what a person earned. Kids arrived with homemade capes, store-bought princess dresses, cardboard robots, plastic vampire teeth, and tremendous hopes for the contents of a candy bowl. Some families could afford elaborate decorations that flashed and moved. Others set out one pumpkin on a stool. For those few hours the street belonged to the children, and I liked watching the adults relax. The first Halloween after I moved in, a little boy dressed as a firefighter told me that the smiling skeleton on my porch wasn't scary enough. I added a crooked hat the following year, and he returned to approve it. Traditions started that way, almost without permission.
Three days before the trouble, I was testing the lights with an outlet meter when Vivian crossed the street. She stood beside the pumpkins and watched me secure an extension cord beneath a protective cable cover. The big candy bowl was empty then, set out only so I could see whether it might blow off the step. Vivian asked whether I planned to attract hundreds of children. I said I hoped at least a few came, because otherwise Renee would spend the week eating chocolate she didn't need. Vivian did not smile. She said our street was not supposed to encourage strangers to approach private houses, and that some people had no understanding of appropriate boundaries.
"Are you talking about trick-or-treating?" I asked. "Because I think that's the whole idea."
"I'm talking about protecting the neighborhood," she replied. "Not everybody who comes here belongs here."