Karen Threw a Brick Through My Brand-New Window — Then Her Paychecks Started Coming to Me

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

We want painful. I want her to pay for the window. I said pitch posh. The window is peanuts. We sue for the window.

Then we sue for emotional distress, the trauma. You can't sleep in your own home. You live in fear of flying masonry. We sue for loss of use of the living room. We sue for the cost of the upgraded security system you had to install because of her previous harassment.

We can tie that in. And of course, legal fees. He started scribbling figures on a yellow pad. The numbers were getting very large, very fast. We're going to bury this Karen under a mountain of paperwork so high she'll need oxygen to climb out, Saul declared.

The first step was serving her the lawsuit papers. Saul explained that people like Brenda evade process servers like it's an Olympic sport. If they can't hand you the papers, the lawsuit can't start. Leave it to me, Saul said with a wink. Two nights later, a pizza delivery car pulled up to Brenda's house.

A young guy got out carrying a large pepperoni pizza box. He rang the bell. Brenda answered the door. We watched on my security camera. I didn't order a pizza.

She snapped. Uh, is this 4002 Elmwood order for Brenda paid for by a secret admirer? The kid improvd beautifully. Brenda paused. Vanity warded with suspicion.

Vanity won. She opened the door wider to take the pizza. As soon as her hands touched the box, the kid flipped open the lid. Inside wasn't a pepperoni pizza. It was a thick stack of legal documents glued to the cardboard.

"Brenda Johnson, "You are served," the kid yelled, snapping a photo of her holding the box with his phone, then sprinting back to his car like he'd just pulled a heist. "Brenda stood there, holding a cardboard box full of lawsuits, her mouth a gape. Then she let out a screech that probably frightened bats. " three towns over and threw the box onto her own lawn. Too late. The game was a foot.

Brenda, in her infinite wisdom, decided not to hire a lawyer. She posted a long, rambling manifesto on the neighborhood Facebook group about how lawyers are parasites of the deep state and how she would represent herself because truth is my shield. Saul read the post and almost wept with joy. A proy litigant who thinks she's smarter than the system. Jack, Christmas came early.

The court ordered mediation first. This is where you sit in a room with a neutral third party and try to hammer out a deal before a judge gets involved. It's supposed to be civilized. We met in a sterile conference room at the courthouse. I was there with Saul, who was wearing his most intimidating pinstripe suit.

Brenda was there alone, armed with three oversized binders filled with what looked like internet printouts. The mediator was a soft-spoken elderly man named Mr. Henderson, who looked like he just wanted everyone to get along. He started by asking Brenda for her side of the story. Brenda stood up.

She didn't speak. She performed. Mr. Henderson, what you have here is a classic case of entrapment and psychological warfare waged by this man. She pointed at me against a defenseless woman.

She opened a binder. Siron, it was full of blurry photos of my house during construction. Exhibit A. The chaos, the noise. He was running industrial machinery at all hours, aimed specifically at my bedroom window to deprive me of sleep.

We have timestamped video proving all work was done between 8 a.m. And 6:00 p.m., Saul interjected smoothly. Fabricated, Brenda yelled. And the brick? Yes, a brick went through his window.

But who's to say it wasn't an act of God or a vagrant? Or as I suspect Jack himself in a desperate bid for attention. Brenda, Mr. Henderson said gently, "There is 4K video of you throwing the brick. The police have it.

We have it. The judge will have it. " Brenda froze. She seemed to reboot her brain. Well, if I did throw it, which I don't admit, it was justified self-defense. The noise was assaulting me.

Anor it was a preemptive strike against sonic violence. Saul leaned back, grinning. So, your argument is that you threw a brick in self-defense against hammering at 2 p.m. You're twisting my words, you shy. Brenda turned on the mediator.

And you? You're biased. I can see it in your eyes. You're part of the construction cabal. Mr.

Henderson is a retired family court judge, Brenda. Saul said. He's a patriarchal stoogge. Brenda gathered up her binders. This mediation is a sham.

I will see you in real court where real justice prevails. I will not be silenced by the drywall industrial complex. She stormed out, knocking over a potted plant on her way. Mr. Henderson sighed, pulled a flask from his jacket pocket, poured a shot into his coffee, and looked at Saul.

"See you at trial," or counselor. The trial was less a legal proceeding and more a public execution of Brenda's ego. It took place in a civil courtroom before Judge Ramirez, a nononsense woman who looked like she didn't suffer fools, gladly or otherwise. Brenda showed up wearing an outfit that I think was supposed to look professional, but looked more like she was auditioning for a role as a quirky, whimsical baker in a Hallmark movie. Lots of scarves and jingling bracelets.

Saul's opening statement was brief. Your honor, the defendant threw a brick through my client's window because she doesn't like construction noise during business hours. We have it on video. She then refused to pay the bill and threw feces at my client's property. We have that on video, too.

We ask for full damages. Brenda's opening statement lasted 20 minutes. It covered the history of property rights dating back to the Magna Carta, her severe allergy to dust vibrations, a conspiracy theory about Tony the contractor being an ex CIA operative, and a claim that my house was built on an ancient lay line that I was disrupting. Judge Ramirez looked at her over her reading glasses multiple times, asking, "Miss Johnson, do you have a legal point to make related to the broken window? It's all connected, your honor.

You have to see the tapestry, Brenda insisted. Then came the evidence phase. Saul simply hooked up his laptop to the courtroom screen and pressed play. The jury, yes, Brenda demanded a jury, thinking they would sympathize with her plight, watched the brick video. They watched it in regular speed.

They watched it in slow motion. They watched it zoomed in on Brenda's determined face. Then Saul played the poop throwing video. A collective gasp went through the jury box. One juror actually covered her mouth.

Brenda, sitting at the defendant's table, looked incredibly smug. She whispered loud enough for everyone to hear. See, he was harassing me with envelopes. It was time for cross-examination. Saul approached the stand where Brenda was sitting, looking like a cat about to toy with a particularly slow mouse.

Miss Johnson, Saul began. You stated in your opening monologue. Sorry. Statement that you didn't throw the brick, but if you did, it was self-defense. Which is it?

It's both. It's Schroinger's brick, counselor. It exists in a state of quantum uncertainty until observed by true justice. The judge rubbed her temples. Okay.

News in the same category

Karen Threw a Brick Through My Brand-New Window — Then Her Paychecks Started Coming to Me

5 Part