The log shows he swiped in at 9:47 p. m. The robbery occurred at 9:52 p. m. 3 mi away. How do you explain? Cole's gavvel cracked. Mr. Lester, the court has already noted that electronic card swipes are easily falsified. A friend could have swiped on his behalf.
This evidence is inadmissible. Move on. Lester opened his mouth, closed it, moved on. Cole leaned back in his chair, and adjusted his glasses. He looked at Trayvon the way a man looks at something stuck to the bottom of his shoe.
Let me ask you directly, Mr. Wells. His voice was conversational, almost friendly. Almost. Do you have anyone, a parent, a mentor, a pastor, anyone of standing who can speak to your character? Trayvon's lawyer started to respond, but Cole raised a hand.
I'm asking him. Trayvon looked up. My mother is here, your honor. Third row. Cole glanced at Diane up and down the worn purse, the old dress, the scrubs peeking out from under the hem where she hadn't changed completely.
Anyone else? No, sir. Cole wrote something on his pad. No father in the picture, I take it. It wasn't a question.
It was a label. Noted, Cole said, and turned the page. The prosecution rested after 40 minutes. They had a blurry video and a detective's hunch. That was all.
Lester stood for his closing. He tried. He talked about reasonable doubt. He talked about the swipe log, the distance, the timeline. He cited two precedents involving misidentification.
Cole listened with his eyes half closed. When Lester finished, the judge didn't respond to a single point. Instead, he looked at Trayvon. Stand up. Trayvon stood.
Cole stared at him for a long time. The courtroom was silent. I've sat on this bench for 30 years, Mr. Wells. 30 Years. And in that time, I've seen hundreds of young men just like you walk through that door.
He pointed toward the side entrance where Trayvon had been brought in. Same neighborhood, same story, same hoodie. He paused. Same excuses. Diane's breath caught.
Her knuckles went white on the purse strap. Every single one of them told me they were innocent. Every single one had some story. They were somewhere else. Someone else did it.