His hands were covered in blood. Parked 10 ft away was his custom Harley-Davidson. Inside the leather saddle bag of that bike, investigators found a steel tire iron smeared with blood that matched Coburn's rare AB negative type. For the police and subsequently for District Attorney Vanderbeek, it was the easiest collar of the decade. A violent Hell's Angel caught red-handed at the scene of a brutal assault on arrival.
It was textbook gang warfare. But Timothy Finch, despite his rumpled appearance and overwhelming case load, was a meticulous lawyer. When he finally got the discovery files, he began to notice the jagged edges of the prosecution's perfect case. First, there was the blood on Grizzly's hands. The police report noted it, but the lab report showed that the blood on his knuckles belonged to Grizzly himself.
He had deep lacerations on his palms, the kind of cuts one gets from gripping something sharp, not from bludgeoning someone. Second, the bartender's testimony was wildly inconsistent. She claimed to have seen Grizzly walk into the alley right after Coburn, but security camera footage from a nearby gas station showed Grizzly arriving on his motorcycle a full 20 minutes times after times Coburn had already stumbled out the back door. Most troubling of all was the tire iron. Finch knew the Hell's Angels.
He had studied their history, reading up on the legendary codes of conduct established by founding figures like Sunny Berger, an experienced sergeant-at-arms like Grizzly, a man whose sole job was to enforce discipline and protect the club's interests, would never commit a sloppy, chaotic assault and then leave the murder weapon inside his own saddle bag while casually smoking a cigarette at the scene. It was completely antithetical to the precision and operational security of a veteran outlaw. Grizzly had been set up. Finch knew it in his bones. He visited the county jail three times a week, sitting in the bleak fluorescent lit interview room, sliding photographs and crime scene reports across the metal table. "
Look at the timeline, Grizzly, " Finch pleaded during one particularly desperate visit, tapping his pen against the gas station stills. You weren't even there when Coburn got hit. You arrived later. Whoever beat him tossed that iron into your bag before the cops swarmed the place. You're covering for someone or someone used you as a convenient fall guy because they knew your patch would blind the cops to any other suspects.
Grizzly sat across from him. His massive arms crossed over his orange jumpsuit. He stared at the cinder block wall behind Finch's head. " Is it a brother? " Finch asked, lowering his voice.
Are you taking the fall for someone in the chapter? Because if you are, I need to know how to maneuver around it. I can create reasonable doubt without naming names. But I need you to give me a thread to pull. Just one word.
Grizzly. Nothing. The man was a fortress of flesh and bone. Finch sighed, rubbing his temples. Judge Fitzgerald is out for blood.
He's trailing in the polls for the appellet seat. He needs to look tough on crime, and you are his golden goose. He is not going to allow me any leeway. If we go to trial blind, he will ensure the jury convicts you. You will die in Falsome prison.