Judge Jailed a Court Observer Overnight — Next Morning, His Clerk Told Him Who She Was

Chapter 13

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The heavy silence of people realizing they were watching something historic. Fourth document. " 17 Formal complaints have been filed against Judge Whitfield since 2009. Complaints alleging racial bias, excessive sentencing, denial of due process, and verbal abuse of defendants. Not one of these complaints resulted in a hearing.

Not one resulted in disciplinary action. Not one was even formally acknowledged. She closed the folder. Judge Whitfield did not make a mistake when he jailed me. He did exactly what he has been doing for 30 years.

The only difference is that this time the person he silenced had the ability to speak back. Prescott attempted a cross-examination. He asked whether Olivia had identified herself as chair of the state bar when she entered the courtroom. No. She said.

I identified myself as a member of the bar and a court observer. So the judge had no way of knowing Knowing what? Olivia said. Her voice was still calm, but something in it shifted. A weight that hadn't been there before.

That I mattered? That's exactly the point, counselor. Every person in that courtroom mattered. Denise Holloway mattered. The man who got 60 days for a first offense mattered.

The grandmother who cried during her grandson's sentencing mattered. They all mattered. The only person in that room who didn't understand that was sitting behind the bench. Prescott had no follow-up. He sat down.

The commission deliberated for less than 3 hours. The ruling was unanimous. Judge Harold Whitfield was permanently removed from the bench, effective immediately. His judicial pension was suspended pending further review. His law license was referred to the state bar for disciplinary proceedings.

When the ruling was read, Whitfield sat motionless. His attorney whispered something in his ear. Whitfield didn't respond. He stared at the table in front of him. The same table, the same angle, the same view that thousands of defendants had stared at in his courtroom when they were waiting to hear their fate.

For the first time in 30 years, he was on the other side. He left the hearing room through a side door. No statement, no press conference. A photographer caught him walking to his car, head down, shoulders hunched, his attorney holding an umbrella over him even though it wasn't raining. The photo ran on the front page of every major newspaper in the state.

The headline in the Birmingham News read, "The judge who taught himself a lesson. " Outside the hearing room, reporters asked Olivia for a comment. She gave them one sentence. " Today, the system worked. Tomorrow, we make sure it keeps working. "

Then she announced her next move. She would be drafting a bill, the Judicial Accountability Act. Mandatory bias training for every sitting judge, anonymous complaint systems, independent sentencing audits every 3 years, and a fast-track review process so that no complaint sits in a drawer for a decade while a judge keeps destroying lives. She didn't elaborate further. She walked to her car, set her briefcase on the passenger seat, and drove back to Birmingham.

There was a courthouse in Selma she'd been meaning to visit. Six months later, the Judicial Accountability Act passed the Alabama State Legislature. The vote was 31 to 4 in the Senate and 89 to 16 in the house. The governor signed it on a Friday afternoon in a ceremony that was broadcast live. Olivia Turner stood 3 ft behind him, hands folded, watching the pen move across the page.

News in the same category

Judge Jailed a Court Observer Overnight — Next Morning, His Clerk Told Him Who She Was

14 Part