The removal was requested not by the association but by the limited liability company. The owner paid somewhere between $500 and $900 to recover the vehicle, and a percentage of every payment flowed back toward the neighborhood into a fund that the association's own treasurer had never seen on any budget. Sheriff Pike reviewed the table with him on a Saturday afternoon, standing with his arms folded, reading every page. "This is a pattern," he said finally. It might be fraud.
It might be abuse of authority. It might be a badly written contract run by people who didn't understand it. I can't tell a prosecutor which one yet. He tapped the table. "What you need is the money—where it actually went.
That's the part that turns a pattern into a case." The answer came from a place Elias had not expected. Gideon Vail ran a small independent garage on the edge of town. He had been servicing Elias's truck for 6 years. When Elias brought him the borrowed sedan to check a noise in its brakes, Gideon mentioned almost casually that he had heard about the tow.
Then he set down his wrench and said something else. "I've seen that woman at the impound yard before." Elias waited. "Back in the spring, I was out there picking up a customer's car. She came in right after a tow."
Gideon said he had noticed her because she did not act like someone retrieving a vehicle. She had walked around the new arrival once, glanced at it, and then gone straight into the back office with the owner of the lot. The door had closed. She had stayed nearly 20 minutes. When she came out, she was folding an envelope into her purse.
Then he reached under the counter, pulled out a battered accordion folder, and began flipping through old papers. He found what he was looking for near the back. It was an invoice from the impound lot, 8 months old, that had been accidentally stapled to the paperwork for his customer's car. It was an internal payment record. At the bottom was a line item that read Community Enforcement Commission, followed by a dollar amount and a wire transfer to an account number.
The account was not listed under the name of the Silver Pines Homeowners Association. It was not listed under any name at all. There was only the routing number and the account number printed in faded ink. Elias photographed the invoice and thanked Gideon. That night, he sat at his dining room table with a lamp and the old closing file from the purchase of his house.
Deep inside, among the title disclosures from Walter Hale's old dispute, was a settlement payment instruction from the year the association had dropped its claim to the creek land. It directed that certain legal fees be wired to the trust account of the Kincaid Law Firm. Elias laid the invoice from Gideon's folder beside it. He read the numbers once, then again, digit by digit. they matched. The commission from the towing of Silver Pines cars was being deposited into the account of the law firm of Marlowe Kincaid.