She said the development would raise property values, improve drainage infrastructure, and bring long-term benefits to the entire area. She said some residents had allowed personal emotion to obstruct a project that affected hundreds of homeowners.
I knew she meant me.
I stood before Naomi could stop me, then forced myself to sit back down until Thomas recognized me.
When he did, I walked to the microphone with no speech prepared.
"You keep calling my decision emotional," I said. "I read the easement. I had an engineer review it. The access period could have lasted eighteen months. The trench alignment came within fourteen feet of my daughter's room. I said no because it was my property and the terms were bad for my family."
Elaine folded her hands.
I continued. "You had the right to disagree with me. Landmark had the right to offer more money. The HOA had the right to discuss neighborhood impacts. None of you had the right to make 'no' cost me a year of selective enforcement."
Then I looked toward the photograph Naomi had placed on the screen behind me.
It was taken twelve years earlier. Jasmine was kneeling beside the magnolia when it was barely taller than her shoulder. I stood behind her holding baby Ava, whose pink hat was too big for her head.
I had not planned to use the picture.
Ava had brought it.
"And you definitely didn't have the right to erase something from my yard because it stood where a developer wanted a survey crew to go."
Elaine's face tightened. "Nobody erased your wife."
Ava stood.
I turned toward her.
She had tears in her eyes but her voice was steady.
"Then stop talking about the tree like it was only a tree."
Nobody moved.
She walked beside me carrying the brass wind chime.
"My mom planted it when I came home from the hospital. Dad measured me on it every birthday. When Mom got sick, she used to sit under it because she said the shade made chemo days feel less ugly. After she died, I could see it from my bedroom."
Elaine looked down.
Ava continued. "You didn't have to care about any of that. You just had to ask before cutting something that wasn't yours."
Then she placed the wind chime on the table and sat back down.
Naomi did not say another word for almost ten seconds.