Then she asked whether Naomi was renting or buying, whether she lived alone, and why a woman with her qualifications had chosen such an unremarkable house. Naomi accepted the basket, offered no personal history, and watched Evelyn's smile grow thinner with every unanswered question.
By the end of the first week, Naomi had received two parking warnings despite keeping her sedan in the driveway, where the rules explicitly allowed it. A neighbor named Carol Fenwick photographed her carrying grocery bags and announced that the association encouraged residents to report unfamiliar activity.
Someone moved the recycling bin from beside Naomi's garage to the sidewalk, then fined her for leaving it there overnight. The incidents were irritating rather than frightening, which was precisely why Naomi documented them carefully. Harassment designed to appear trivial could continue for years if each act was treated as an isolated misunderstanding.
Naomi's contact on the task force, Special Agent Daniel Mercer, reviewed her notes during their scheduled call. Daniel was forty-five, a patient man whose calm manner hid an exceptional memory for financial records. He told her the contractor had recently added a service called Resident Integrity Monitoring, marketed as protection against trespassers and fraudulent tenants. Customers paid monthly fees, but several payments flowed through consulting firms owned by relatives of HOA board members. Naomi suspected the monitoring service was a cover for collecting private data and identifying residents who questioned association spending.
Her first significant discovery came from an elderly neighbor named Ruth Ellis. Ruth was seventy-two and lived alone with a terrier called Peanut, who barked at anyone wearing sunglasses. She approached Naomi while Naomi was repairing a loose fence latch and asked whether the HOA had begun sending her strange letters. Ruth had received notices claiming she violated landscaping rules, even though she had not changed her garden in fifteen years. When she appealed, the association threatened to suspend her access to the community pool and charge additional administrative fees.
Ruth lowered her voice and explained that her grandson had helped her examine the invoices. The same security company appeared on every bill, including one charging the association for patrols on nights when the gate cameras showed no patrol vehicle. Ruth had raised the issue at a board meeting and was told she misunderstood modern accounting. Two days later, someone left a dead bird on her doorstep with a note warning her to mind her own business. Naomi photographed the note and asked Ruth to keep the original in a sealed envelope.